Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
17 comments
10 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/23/2009
This is hard,really really hard. I love both movies. WOW,what a tough one this is.
on 12/19/2009
Both are fantastic movies. Wall-E is amazing in every way.
on 12/21/2009
Toy Story and its sequel might have the edge in nostalgia, but that's it. Wall-E is simply perfection.
on 2/19/2010
I still love the sweetness of "Toy Story 2" and its exploration of finding one's place in the world. That said, "Wall-E" was far more ambitious, and conveyed a valuable social message about not shirking our responsibilities at the expense of our future.
on 4/5/2010
Holy crap! This is a tough call but I'm gonna have to say Wall-E. I still cry thinking of Jessie's song "When Somebody Loved Me".
on 4/18/2010
Toy Story 2. I just don't think Wall-E retains its entertainment value as much as its charm with multiple viewings.
on 4/25/2011
Wall-E was another move of Pixar toward self-indulgence and preachiness and away from good storytelling. Toy Story 2 is better hands down.
on 7/20/2011
good ol' Pixar :)
on 8/16/2011
And of course, I went back to Wall-E. I can never make up my mind on Pixar. -_-
on 3/19/2012
Wall E takes it out.
on 8/9/2012
So hard to pick, but the technical advancements that were made for Wall-e wins me over every time.
on 8/10/2012
I love both, though I have to go with Wall-E.
on 12/25/2012
Toy Story 2 for sure.
on 12/26/2012
Both of these are fantastic films by the wizards of Pixar, but Wall-E is one of the greatest cinematic achievements EVER. Toy Story 2 is great and all (and who didn't cry during "When She Loved Me"?), but Wall-E is absolute perfection.
Toy Story 2
Wall-E....but we're all winners here...
First half of Wall-E > Toy Story 2 >> Second half of Wall-E.
on 2/7/2013
Toy Story 2 all the way. in fact, ANY Toy Story over WALL-E any day for me.
on 2/8/2013
Toy Story 2 :) I disliked Wall E
on 2/10/2014
Tough choice, but Toy Story 2 was more emotionally involving for me.
on 4/19/2014
I haven't seen Wall-E since the theater I remember liking it but for now its going to Toy Story 2
on 4/21/2014
I say WALL•E
Maybe just a bit
on 9/1/2015
Woody and Buzz.
Wall e is overrated. TS2 EASILY
on 12/14/2015
If WALL-E had kept the strength of it's opening act throughout the movie, it would have taken this match-up without a doubt. But it didn't so Toy Story 2 comes out the stronger film for me.
on 2/8/2017
Wall-E
on 4/22/2017
OK, the Toy Story films are starting to get quite overrated these days. Sorry, but the fact is that WALL-E is better than Toy Story 2 here.
on 5/31/2018
WALL-E was much magnificent for me.
Toy Story 2 brings out the inner child in me and I prefer it over Wall-E.
on 10/26/2018
toy story 2 wins this time
on 12/4/2021
WALL-E over all of the Toy Story sequels for me, but not the original Toy Story, so here, WALL-E gets my vote.
on 12/8/2021
Bearing the carp of Disney is hard, but I give the edge to Wall.E
on 9/20/2022
Toy Story 2 was OK. I thought most of it was boring. But WALL-E on the other hand is a masterpiece so it wins here for me.
