Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 12/23/2011
Shutter Island is kind of a mess but that kind of intrigued me. Hugo is a nice film but that's all.
on 12/27/2011
Hugo is a lot more than just nice.
on 2/7/2012
Both movies are more than terrific, but Hugo is just a flat-out masterpeice all the way around. It gets the easy win here!
on 6/20/2013
Loved both, both prove Scorsese's still got it. But I'm going with Hugo.
Shutter Island. I simply loathed Hugo....
on 12/17/2013
Hugo was a pretty gorgeous film, but the story was slightly boring. Shutter Island's plot was more interesting.
on 3/13/2015
Scorsese showdown i will go with shutter island
on 11/17/2015
I didn't get into Shutter Island the first time I watched it but it's ok now. Hugo was the film that really got me going. I wondered where Martin Scorsese would be taking me with Hugo rather then Shutter Island.
on 9/18/2019
I remember the vibrant colors of Shutter Island. Reds, yellows, greens...
Shutter Island of course.