Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
5 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/29/2009
Tough choice indeed. But between these two kings of the underground, I'll go with BOONDOCK SAINTS.
on 1/8/2010
I'm with ya, Fight Club is in my top 50 but the Saints are in my top 10.
on 8/8/2010
This has got to be one of my toughest ones yet. Yet the more I think about it the more I think fight club is better. Fight Club it is.
on 9/16/2010
Fight Club,Boondocks Saints is just okay to me.
on 5/29/2011
The two perfect guy flicks in my opinion. Fight Club had one of the biggest twists while Boondocks had some of the most awesome shootouts, so Boondocks wins.
on 6/6/2011
Both are great, But Boondock Saints Win.
on 10/23/2012
If your little brother who plays Call of Duty and screams "faggot!!! faggot!!!" into his headset all day made a movie, he'd make Boondocks Saints. Then if he started taking philosophy classes at community college, he'd make Fight Club.
*Boondock
on 11/5/2012
Holy shit The Boondock Saints was bad. Seriously some of the worst dialog I've ever heard, and the film as a whole has zero substance. That's just the tip of the iceberg though, I could go on for a while about why I hate The Boondock Saints. Fight Club is probably my favorite film ever at the moment, and these two movies should never be compared.
on 1/2/2015
Boondocks is a harsh violent kick ass film its a film with great characters and the story of a family who become anti-hero vigilantes who want to take back the streets of their Hometown is great! but fight club is a smarter more edgier and witty film! it hits all the right spots for a action film that turns into a drama with a mindbending inner story! and is the clear winner!
Boondock all the way....
Boondock Saints is terrible. Fight Club isn't.
on 6/23/2015
I like them both. Only Love One Of Them. Fight Club wins.
@Fok: I agree with the first part, but I tend to think Fight Club's critics are a tad harsh. He nailed the rest of it, though.
on 9/28/2018
Fight Club all the way.
on 2/5/2020
Fight club is way to pretentious,Boondocks is a very ridiculous movie that knows what it is.
