Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
10 comments
12 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/23/2011
This is a very difficult choice, but I'm going to go with Toy Story 3. Maybe it's because I'm a teen going to college and can relate to the plot of TS3, but I still believe that The Incredibles is the second or third best super-hero movie ever made (behind the Dark Knight and possibly Spider Man 2).
on 11/3/2011
Tough, tough, tough.
on 4/8/2012
One of the greatest superhero movies ever vs one of the saddest movies ever. Both are good, but only one is amazing.
on 6/1/2012
Toy Story 3 wins by a hair.
This is just abuse by Toy Story 3....it owns The Incredibles....
on 8/26/2012
Don't get me wrong; I love the Incredibles. I just think that Toy Story 3 is far superior.
on 1/22/2013
The Incredibles wins for me but Toy Story 3 was great!
on 1/27/2013
OMG these 2 are my favorite pixar movies......
on 6/13/2013
One is a good animated movie, while the other is great. Toy Story 3 wins...
on 6/14/2013
The Incredibles is my favorite Pixar movie...if you don't count the Toy Story Trilogy.
on 7/4/2013
TS3 but not by much.
on 1/30/2014
The Toys, man. The truckin' toys.
on 1/31/2014
Toy Story 3 is the better movie.
TS3
on 3/28/2015
The Incredibles! Toy Story 3 is the #8 in my rank Pixar, and The Incredibles is #7
on 5/15/2015
Incredibles all the way, please.
on 8/13/2015
Incredibles
on 12/6/2015
As said before, Toy Story 3 is my favorite Pixar movie - and one of my favorite movies, period. The Incredibles is very, very good, but Toy Story 3 is on another level.
on 5/9/2017
the incredibles wins
on 5/23/2018
What a tough choice, but I'll go with Toy Story 3.
on 9/29/2019
I really love both of them. But I think I'm gonna go with The Incredibles.
on 3/21/2022
The Incredibles is Pixar's best movie. Toy Story 3 is amazing, and much better than the original, but it just doesn't top The Incredibles to me.
on 4/20/2022
OH COME ONE I just had to decide between Toy Story 3 and WALL-E and now I get this??? :o Definitely a matter of personal preference this one, but TS3 is just a little nearer & dearer to me
I like The Incredibles as much as the next person, but somehow I don't have to think very hard on this one: Toy Story 3.
on 6/26/2022
The Incredibles without a doubt for me. Not that Toy Story 3's a bad movie. I love Toy Story 3 as well, but The Incredibles edges every Pixar film for me.
on 10/23/2022
I love The Incredibles, but Toy Story 3 beats any animated superhero movies