Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
5 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/15/2017
Oh, this one's tough. Two distopian, generation-ahead franchise installments that aren't strictly sequels. I'm going to give it to Blade Runner 2049 for its amazing visuals and for significantly enhancing the universe it inhabits.
on 10/23/2017
Two of the year's best - but Blade Runner 2049 is showstopping.
on 10/25/2017
Logan for more action, better pacing. and an overall more satisfying story. Neo-Western > Neo-Noir
on 10/26/2017
they have both shitty villains but logan has better story-telling and characterization
on 6/14/2018
I enjoy Blade Runner 2049 for me more than Logan here.
This one is generally tough since both are in my 3 favourite movies of 2017. Blade Runner has a more complex story, a better setting and the filmmaking is fantastic. But I have to give it to Logan. It’s a great character study about growing old and family yet still stands on its own as a great action movie!
Blade Runner 2049 is the stunning winner here.
on 7/15/2018
no competition here, blade runner 2049 all the way
on 4/17/2019
I've very divided: Logan wins for its characters, but remembering the sights and/or sounds of 2049 feels better. I hate voting against craftsmanship, but I say Logan wins.
on 12/9/2020
Blade Runner 2049 FTW!!! Wasn't much of a fan of Logan
on 2/1/2021
Blade Runner 2049 is the best sequel of 2017, and this is coming from a gigantic X-Men fan! Logan was also a masterpiece though, but it’s still not as good as Blade Runner 2049.
on 2/2/2021
Logan isn't all that but did anyone actually watch Blade Runner 20WHOCARES?
on 6/14/2021
2049 is more impressive in terms of filmmaking but Logan is more emotional and satisfying.
on 10/21/2021
Get Out is better than both
Tough call, but I'm thinking Logan
on 10/26/2021
Denis Villeneuve is better than James Mangold
Logan wins a close one...
on 11/1/2021
Fun fact: Both movies were written by Michael Green
on 11/11/2021
Blade Runner 2049 is more Oscar worthy than Logan
on 4/25/2022
I changed my mind, both are great and Oscar worthy.