Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/4/2009
why are you making me compair such crappy sequles, i don't know which one was worse
on 12/11/2009
These both sucked. Spiderman should win just because it's Spiderman, but it should also live up to a higher level because it's Spiderman. Didn't really care that Hellboy wasn't good, but Spidey 3 hurt.
on 12/12/2009
I understand the hate for Spider-Man 3. Don't agree with it entirely, because I didn't mind Spider-Man 3, but I can understand it. Hellboy II, though? I consider it perhaps the best sequel I have seen to date. On the subject of Spider-Man 3, even it is superior to Hellboy, I feel. If it were not for Guillermo del Toro directing, I'd not have even finished watching Hellboy. On the other hand, Hellboy II felt like a reboot more than a sequel. I'd say it's easily one of the best comic book superhero films yet.
on 11/1/2010
Hellboy II sucked?
Hellboy II surprised me. I liked it better than the first one.
on 12/21/2010
Spider-man was ruined with the emo dance scene. It was also horrible the way they played venom.
on 1/9/2011
Alright, Spider-man 3 wasn't as bad as everybody seems to think it is. It may not be great, but God knows its better than Batman and Robin. Hellboy II is the better film though because Sath McFarlene is hilarious, as is the Ade Sapian actor, and Ron Paulmen kicks butt as Hellboy.
on 6/25/2011
It's hard to argue against the imagination on display in Hellboy II. For some reason, I prefer the first (just slightly; it's a toss-up), but both beat the hell out of Spider-Man 3, and even the first Spider-Man. The Golden Army is not as great a sequel as Spidey 2, but Spidey 3 is no competition whatsoever.
on 7/2/2013
golden army is so much better.
Honestly I'm going with Spider-Man 3. I didn't like Hellboy II.
on 10/23/2018
Spider-Man 3 is light-years ahead of anything Hellboy. The source material alone outclasses it by a factor of 1000000.
Golden Army was enjoyment while Spidey 3 is mediocre and forgettable in every way.
on 11/6/2019
Hellboy II has great characters and motivation while the third Spider-Man film was the most disappointing in every way it did.
on 9/6/2022
Is this even fair? Golden Army by a factor of 100000000.
on 9/11/2022
Golden Army improved on the first movie by a lot and is a great example of a successful sequel, Spider-Man 3... Let's just say it isn't.
