Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
13 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/19/2010
Dammit!!!!
on 6/19/2010
Shawshank.
Toy Story. It's original and it's more inspiring. Pixar rules.
on 6/20/2010
I have a slight preference for Shawshank.
on 7/2/2010
I'm a Pixar fanatic. And while my appreciation for Shawshank is growing, and I do really like the film, I don't love it that much. Toy Story, it is.
on 7/28/2010
probably the most difficult decision of my life
on 9/21/2010
Shawshank, easily
on 12/20/2010
Toy Story, although it pains me to say it.
on 5/8/2012
hi
on 8/19/2012
Both in my Top 10, but Shawshank owns
Shawshank....but seriously....both are off the charts.
I like me some Toy Story, but it doesn't have that extremely high nostalgia factor for me, unlike for most people, simply because I didn't grew up with any of the movies. I saw them at a much older age. Shawshank Redemption wins.
on 12/9/2013
Shawshank is way better
on 4/13/2014
Top ten Toy Story
on 4/18/2014
Both in my top ten Toy Story slide a tiny bit
on 3/22/2016
Woody, Buzz, et al. were instant friends; SHAWSHANK kinda bored me, if I'm being honest. I owe it a more current viewing, but for now this is an easy win for TOY STORY.
I saw Shawshank only on 2014, and it didn't aged very well Imo. Toy Story wins by the nostalgia factor.
on 9/14/2016
Both movies are impactful, but Shawshank is more enjoyable imo.
on 6/17/2018
Both are brilliant of the 90s but Shawshank is better effort here...
My slight preference for Shawshank has shifted to Toy Story.
on 8/8/2020
Shawshank is enjoyable enough but cmon Toy story you Philistines
on 6/6/2023
Shawshank, no contest. But that’s not saying much Shawshank rarely gets beaten on my chart.
on 6/7/2023
Although I think it's overrated Shawshank wins here.