The Shawshank Redemption vs. Toy Story

13 comments

8 comments

Dammit!!!!

JRM
JRM

Shawshank.

Toy Story. It's original and it's more inspiring. Pixar rules.

ear
ear

I have a slight preference for Shawshank.

I'm a Pixar fanatic. And while my appreciation for Shawshank is growing, and I do really like the film, I don't love it that much. Toy Story, it is.

probably the most difficult decision of my life

Shawshank, easily

Toy Story, although it pains me to say it.

hi

Both in my Top 10, but Shawshank owns

Shawshank....but seriously....both are off the charts.

I like me some Toy Story, but it doesn't have that extremely high nostalgia factor for me, unlike for most people, simply because I didn't grew up with any of the movies. I saw them at a much older age. Shawshank Redemption wins.

Shawshank is way better

Top ten Toy Story

Both in my top ten Toy Story slide a tiny bit

Woody, Buzz, et al. were instant friends; SHAWSHANK kinda bored me, if I'm being honest. I owe it a more current viewing, but for now this is an easy win for TOY STORY.

I saw Shawshank only on 2014, and it didn't aged very well Imo. Toy Story wins by the nostalgia factor.

Both movies are impactful, but Shawshank is more enjoyable imo.

Both are brilliant of the 90s but Shawshank is better effort here...

ear
ear

My slight preference for Shawshank has shifted to Toy Story.

Shawshank is enjoyable enough but cmon Toy story you Philistines

Shawshank, no contest. But that’s not saying much Shawshank rarely gets beaten on my chart.

Although I think it's overrated Shawshank wins here.