High Noon vs. Shane



Two classics...though choice, but High Noon wins it.

Two classics, indeed...I favor Shane in this matchup, but High Noon is a hell of a western as well.

High Noon is probably more timeless than Shane, and that might be one of the reasons I have it higher on my chart than Shane. That and the memorable score.

High Noon squeaks by in the closest of margins...

Going with High Noon here. That said I LOVE Shane.

High Noon wins for me.

High Noon is just missing... something. Thus Shane gets the edge.