Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
10 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/5/2009
Not a fan of either of these, though I did enjoy the Dodo joke in 'Ice Age', so I guess its better.
on 11/15/2009
There are few films that I truly hate... these are two of the biggest offenders. I didn't laugh once during either of these, and it's a toss-up over which was more poisonous to my soul. I'm going to say ICE AGE is better because I like the voice talent better, and I really, really hate Mike Myers.
on 2/10/2010
I thought Shrek was far more funny than Ice Age.
on 8/2/2010
The first Shrek was incredibly funny and therefore wins here. In the sequel department Ice Age would win though.
on 9/24/2010
Both of these are terrible, but at least one didn't feature a song by Smashmouth.
on 3/14/2011
Shrek was muuuuch better. Ice Age didn't find a way to make me laugh as hard, as I did and do for donkey!
on 2/6/2013
Ice Age hasn't aged well and it just gets dumber with every viewing.
It was all downhill for each of these franchises after these movies. I can understand the hate for either of them, but I think they're both at least decent. I kind of agree with rob, though. Shrek gets by for the win.
Shrek
on 2/19/2013
ummm both movies shit but shrek just alittle bit less shitter
on 6/9/2013
Shrek is quite superior, but Ice Age is also really good.
on 4/9/2015
DreamWorks fights Fox Corporation
Both were great to watch as a kid but Shrek is a film I still really enjoy to this day.
on 9/30/2015
*Snicker* Are you happy?
on 6/6/2018
i liked both but i mostly prefer Ice Age
I enjoyed Ice Age a little bit more.
Shrek and it's not close.
