Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
5 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 6/29/2009
I gotta go with Nightmare as it was slightly less silly than Batman Returns.
on 7/16/2009
I go with Nightmare, but not because I don't like Batman Returns. I'd pick Batman over Batman Returns, but if it were between, oh, say Beetlejuice and Nightmare Before Christmas.....that'd be a tough one....
on 8/30/2009
I'm going with 'Batman Returns' as its my favorite pre-Nolan Batman film and I thought the story and everything was a bit more there than 'Nightmare'.
on 11/18/2009
Really now. With a year between the two its a tough choice. But I'm going to have to go with Batman Returns on this one.
on 4/8/2010
I'll have to say Nightmare but I was pretty young when I saw Batman Returns and it scared the crap out of me.
on 5/15/2010
Love the stuff in "Returns" with Selina/Catwoman, but hate the stuff with DeVito's Penguin. "Nightmare" wins for being more consistent, and for being full of stylish ambiance.
on 4/28/2013
Batman returns
I actually liked Returns better than the first one. Batman gets the nod here.
on 3/29/2015
Returns had major issues, but it is still a better movie than Nightmare.
on 6/17/2015
Nightmare is the best Tim Burton film ever.