Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
5 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/30/2009
What to do!
on 2/11/2011
"What to do?" Really?
on 10/12/2011
I've read arguments that both these films run off the rails in the final act. I don't buy it, personally; I love them both all the way through. But Up does blow it's load in the first ten minutes; that opening montage is pure filmmaking magic. And the best stuff in TDK is in the middle; most specifically, the interrogation scene. I love both of these movies very, very much. Up touched me in a way that few films have, but I just LIKE The Dark Knight better. I seem to use that argument a lot when I'm talking about that movie; perhaps it's just something intangible that I haven't really put my finger on yet...
on 3/2/2012
The Dark Knight. It had a bigger impact on the year it was released and it truly did deserve the Best Picture win if not that than the nomination.
on 3/5/2012
Even though I'm not a Marvel fan at all, I'm going with The Dark Knight here. Up was a tad bit disappointing for a Pixar, even more so after the masterpiece that Wall-E was.
I think RB meant to say DC, but I agree with the rest of his comment. Up, IMHO, really is overrated (not bad, just overrated).
on 12/11/2012
TDK. Up is a movie that I actually like less with each viewing...
on 6/25/2014
Up by just a wee little bit.
up is the better film
on 5/16/2021
Up has an incredible first ten minutes and simply great rest. TDK is awesome throughout.
