Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/12/2010
While I'm really not crazy about either, I'm gonna have to go with Alien3.
Fight Club beats even the first Alien, so it utterly destroys the 3rd one.
on 5/27/2012
I absolutely hate Alien3. It takes everything great about the first two films and craps all over them with a nonsensical storyline and piss-poor performances. That being said, it's still a better movie than Fight Club.
on 12/9/2012
Fight Club destroys all of the Alien movies, the only competition is probably Aliens in terms of that series. David Fincher ruined the Alien series, but with Fight Club he attained a cult following and a film that is still strong of today.
on 6/22/2013
Fight Club crushes here.
on 6/23/2013
Fincher's worst (by far) vs his best. Fight Club in a landslide.
on 2/23/2016
I second mjr256 comment.
on 4/5/2016
Ugh...bad movie vs. bad movie. Alien 3.
on 8/21/2018
One is loved for the wrong reasons, the other is hated for the wrong reasons. Must be frustrating being David Fincher in the 90s...
Alien 3>Fight Club
on 10/2/2018
Fight Club is very overrated but Alien 3 is unwatchable trash in every way!
on 10/23/2019
It's kinda funny that Alien 3 has more votes now, considering that Fight Club is consistently regarded as Fincher's best and Alien 3 as Fincher's worst.
