Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
14 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/24/2009
Hanks & Zemeckis vs Hanks
Hanks & Zemeckis vs Hanks & Zemeckis. Gump is the better film I think.
on 3/28/2010
wow wow wow..... O.O
on 5/29/2010
I'm going to have to go with Forrest Gump.
on 8/3/2010
I never immediately remember the ending of Gump but I'll always remember the ending to Cast Away, that seems like it'd be an indication of which one was better.
on 7/29/2011
Dang.
on 12/17/2011
Two great Tom Hanks films. I gotta go with Forrest Gump because of Bubba.
Forest Gump by a long shot, but both were good films but forest gump is a masterpiece
forrest blah
god I said that because I spelled it wrong not saying it was a bad movie, wheres the edit button at
on 6/25/2012
The acting and directing of Forrest Gump is simply superior to Cast Away.
on 5/25/2014
Gosh I love both both are my favorite Tom Hanks films but Got to go with Forrest Gump
on 8/1/2015
Forrest Gump no question, though the hipsters will choose Cast Away so they can feel like they're making an original choice.
on 10/12/2015
Forrest Gump's magic works better. Cast away loses a lot of steam through the middle act and features an underwhelming ending.
Forrest Gump for me. I'm with robmoviefilms13. Cast Away does lose a bit of steam later on into the movie.
on 11/28/2020
HOW ARE YU SUPPOSED TO DECIDE OUT OF THESE MOVIES
on 11/29/2020
Easy choice Forrest Gump
on 12/13/2021
Castaway extremely underrated. Forrest Gump a bit overrated. The Castaway love story always got to me more than the Forrest Gump love story. Castaway is better.