Isle of Dogs vs. The Nightmare Before Christmas

3 comments

1 comments

on 4/10/2018

Both are great Stop-Motion films, but Isle of Dogs has a much better story.

on 4/16/2018

Isle of Dogs has a clumsy narrative structure, but that seems consonant with the pseudo-Japanese milieu of the film.

on 4/19/2018

Both are flawed in some severe ways, but I think I preferred the good things about Isle of Dogs. If only there weren't all that obnoxious racial insensitivity.

on 5/31/2018

Recently saw IOD and really loved it but doesn´t stand a chance against a classic as The Nightmare Before Christmas