Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
15 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 4/22/2010
And the best film of all time is... The Godfather Part II. Both are amazing though.
on 4/29/2010
The Godfather II is just so epic and has so many great actors and performances. Though Departed is one of my favorites.
on 2/21/2011
Both totally awesome. If there was choice of rating them the same, I would do so, but in this case I have to go with Pacino.
on 2/22/2011
This isn't even a debate. Godfather 2 is everything that's right about film. The Departed is an overrated borderline mess of a film that substitutes shock value and morbid endings for actual substance and good story telling.
on 3/14/2011
Hard decison.both great movies. I watched The Departed the other day for the first time and I was blown away. Very good movie. Great acting and lots of crime. The Godfather 2 was awesome but not in the same lines as The Departed.
on 2/17/2012
The Godfather Pt II is an amazing film from start to finish. It stands rightfully as one of the greatest films of all time.
Two exceptional movies, yet this is not a close run thing.
on 10/8/2012
The Departed is that much better.
on 5/2/2014
Both great but the the rich dialog and great settings with outstanding performances gives Godfather Part 2 the easy win.
on 5/8/2014
Departed
My preference is The Departed, but I understand that most would consider GF II the better movie...
Part II
on 5/29/2014
Tough
on 9/1/2014
GF2 had the better acting, characters and themes/moral aspect. Departed had the better story and dialogue in my opinion. GF2 even had the better direction. But for some reason Im still going with Departed... But they are right next to each other! Im might change this later on
Enjoy both but i prefer The Departed.
The Departed also for me.
on 5/25/2018
The Godfather 2 is so depressive but is amazing, The Departed is more epic and happy
on 5/26/2018
Part ll is that good.
on 7/25/2018
Departed for me.
on 7/26/2018
Departed is more engaging and tonally consistent
on 7/28/2018
I don't really like either of these movies all that much, but I don't get all the hubbub about the departed while the godfather part ii is clearly an excellent film, so I guess that's how I'll choose
on 9/2/2019
The departed stomps.
The Departed.
on 9/3/2019
The Departed easily wins this one.
on 2/25/2020
The Godfather Part II
on 2/26/2020
The Departed
on 7/17/2020
The Departed best plot ever of recommendation.
on 9/11/2022
The Departed is a brilliant movie, but The Godfather Part 2 is quite a bit better.