Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
5 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 6/28/2009
Have to go with The Departed here. Scorsese and DiCaprio are just too good. I would love to pick my man Raimi and choose Spider man, but i'm going with the departed.
on 5/10/2011
As much as I love Spider-Man, I have to go with The Departed because it is just such a good movie and honestly the ending surprised me.
on 5/11/2011
I have no love for any of the Spiderman movies. The Departed was awesome. Easy choice...
The Departed is a classic. Spiderman would not come anywhere near this oscar winning flick.
on 5/12/2011
The Departed's depressing ending and overrated plot means the sane choice is Spider-Man. Take away the names Scorsese and DiCaprio and shoot the film frame for frame and no one would remember this film nor think it any good. This is the classic case of alleged film fans feeling superior and being pretentious because they pretend to like a "Scorsese" classic.
on 5/13/2011
The Departed ain't as good as all that. And neither is Spider-Man. Of the two, I'll pick The Departed. There are only so many origin stories I can take - and this isn't the best. Now Jack Nicholson vs. William Dafoe. There's a screen showdown waiting to happen.
on 3/23/2014
departed, by far
on 3/25/2014
Since it's the original Spider-Man, while it's good, I'll have to go with The Departed.
on 11/29/2014
The Departed.
on 5/21/2018
Departed easily.
Sorry Spidey but The Departed excels here.
Departed felt the need to kill everyone to try and make you care. We cared about Spidey and his crew without the fake emotion and gore.
on 5/23/2018
Enjoyed watching Martin Sheen in both.
Whoops. Wrong Spider-Man.
on 5/24/2018
Love both, but Departed doesn’t have a cringy love story that degraded the film!
on 2/27/2020
The departed
"Departed felt the need to kill everyone to try and make you care." - was right two years ago and is still correct today. Spidey wins.
on 1/28/2022
departed by a massive landslide
Departed stomps any Marvel film.
on 11/13/2022
I love Spider-Man but The Departed beats even the best of Marvel, Lol @ the Marveltard quoting himself