Sign In Now ►
or Create A New Account ►
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
Deserves got nothing to do with it.
Wow. This is a very tough match-up, I love both films. Buuuuutt I gotta go with The Shining. Unforgiven is incredible though.
The Shining easily....
The Shining does win but Unforgiven is my favorite Western
This one's not too hard, The Shining
I'll take The Shining as well but Unforgiven is perfect as well.
Even William Munny is a better father than Jack Torrance :/
Both are superb! Unforgiven was very human and emotional and The Shining was very artistic and complex. Who wins? Well, both are in my top 30 but The Shining is so so good, even better than Unforgiven!