Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/27/2009
DAMN
on 8/2/2009
Oh, man. Manhattan is brilliant and gorgeous, but I think Annie Hall's consistent tone and endless stream of gags edges it out ever so slightly.
on 8/3/2009
Two of Allen's greatest, but I have to give it to Annie Hall, so much wit and originality in that one.
on 8/28/2009
Agreed... ANNIE HALL. It's probably the most impact Woody ever had on cinema, offering us a prototype of the new, improved romantic comedy for anyone brave enough to defy the prevailing formulas. MANHATTAN is such a wonderful film, tho...
on 11/10/2009
I think it's one of the toughest choices I've ever made on this site. But I have to go with Manhattan.
on 12/2/2009
Annie Hall is my favorite Allen movie, but Manhattan is 4th or 5th. Tough one.
on 1/8/2010
Annie Hall is the popular choice, but I prefer Manhattan. The city is a bit more graceful and centered here. A bit more understated in its approach.
on 3/25/2010
Love both these movies, but Manhattan is the one I love most.
on 11/20/2010
hmm thats tough. love manhattan's cinematography but im going with annie hall.
on 7/14/2012
Manhattan has better visuals and a very emotional story, and it's one of my favorite films. But i choose Annie Hall mostly because it's more creative, it's funnier, and I prefer Keaton as Annie rather then Marry. And it's also one of my favorite films
on 5/19/2013
It's a tough call, but I give a slight edge to Manhattan in this matchup. It's amusing how Woody Allen portrays his 42-year-old character's sexual relationship with a 17-year-old girl as if it ISN'T totally perverted. Weirdo.
on 6/14/2013
I'll take Annie Hall. Manhattan is weighed down by heavy neuroticism with little of the humour to break it up. Annie Hall is far more emjoyable.
Manhattan wins a close contest of Woody Allen flicks I don't particularly like all that well...
on 7/13/2013
Annie Hall
on 9/2/2014
Both are very good films from Woody. It's tough, but I'll go with Annie Hall.
on 1/5/2015
Manhattan is a much better crafted and more cynical depiction of the neurotic, intellectual and chauvinistic minds that occupy 70's New York. One of the most prevalent films of its time.
on 4/13/2022
Manhattan is superior to Annie Hall, but neither one is close to Crimes and Misdemeanors.