Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
12 comments
11 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/19/2009
No contest. I dig AoD, but to me, it's easily the weakest of the DEAD trilogy.
both are groovy but my vote goes to Army of Darkness because of the humor
on 11/21/2009
Army of Darkness is the more flawed film, but it is still better in spite of its flaws.
on 1/17/2010
As entertaining as Army of Darkness is, I enjoy the creppiness and the sheer balls to the wall gore of the first one more.
on 5/10/2010
I'm gonna have to go with Evil Dead, simply because it got there first and it's more impressive as a personal and professional achievement. But I find AoD the most consistently entertaining.
on 5/15/2010
Saw all three of the films when they came out, and while I adore AoD, the original made such a massive impression on my just out of high school. Literally so mind-blowing, I saw it three more times that week, dragging different groups of people to it each time. Most of them forgave me... Most...
on 7/22/2010
i'm a fan of all of em, but in this matchup i have to go with the original
on 10/23/2010
Army of Darkness lost all of what the first two films had, and just became a kind of unfunny, generic adventure film. Stick to the formula of Evil Dead, please!
on 2/2/2012
I had a few problems with Army of Darkness. For one, it felt off. A bit different from the first two. But the humor was still. YO she bitch! At some points it felt like the Three Stooges because of the eye poking. The creautres were different. I felt like the people who made the movie felt like the first two were really popular and they wanted to make the third movie more epic, but wanted to go in a difference direction. They obvisouly had a higher budget to work with. The humor was better in AoD, but the first one actually had a better concept. Both were good, but like i said, it felt off. Still very entertaining.
on 5/7/2012
Army of Darkness. It's too damn awesome.
on 6/14/2012
army of darkness is the more enjoyable film in my opinion, but Evil Dead 2 beats them both
I'm going with Army of Darkness. It's groovy.
on 6/20/2012
Evil Dead 2 is great but Army of Darkness is GOLD in my book.
on 7/21/2012
Neither of these touch Evil Dead 2, but I'm giving Army of Darkness the win over the original.
on 9/6/2012
Army of Darkness was the coolest shit ever when I was 13. But The Evil Dead still holds up.
on 4/4/2013
The utter madness of Army of Darkness gives it an edge over The Evil Dead, a movie that is monotonous to the point of being dreadfully boring.
on 4/5/2013
Monotonous, how?
Army of Darkness. I actually think the original Evil Dead is the worst of the three....
on 4/6/2013
An evil demon(s) attacks/possesses some college student in/around a secluded cabin. Then, it happens again. And again. And again. It just gets redundant (for me, anyway).
on 4/7/2013
Army of Darkness
on 4/8/2013
I am not a horror guy so I was very surprised at how much I liked the first one. I expected to like the sequels even more, because they aren't just straight up horror, but I actually liked the first one the best. The Evil Dead wins it.
on 7/1/2013
After rewatching the trilogy I now think that II is the best, but I is still better than III.
on 10/27/2013
The first is my favourite of the trilogy, with II slightly behind and III quite far back in last. I do like all them despite that.
on 4/3/2014
Now I'm going with The Evil Dead on this one but Army of Darkness is still fantastic but I'm going with Evil Dead mainly because it was not as goofy as Army of Darkness was now yes the goofy ness does make it a lot more funnier and fun but it also took away the scary ness feel to it that The first one had which for me I prefer scary over goofy which again the goofy ness made it really fun and original but it did take the scary feel of it away so my choice is out there I will go with The Evil Dead
I don't mind if a horror movie is goofy but I wish they would keep in some of the horror feel in it
on 5/27/2014
Evil Dead still one of the premiere Horror movies Army is more fun and action.the first is the best.
on 5/27/2015
The best of Evil Dead series. Both are sooooooo good, and much better than the second one. It's hard not to pick the epicness of Army of Darkness on this one, but both are sure fantastic.
on 4/20/2020
I don't want e.d. so I will choose a.d.
on 8/9/2022
The second one is easily the best out of the series but between these two, The Evil Dead is the better movie by a small margin.
on 10/31/2022
Army of Darkness easily, I honestly liked the Evil Dead reboot more than the first Evil Dead
