Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
3 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/21/2011
Okay, this one is interesting. While I think many people overrate Fight Club, I can't deny it is an interesting (and, at times, brilliant) film. I give it the edge over Toy Story, another good movie that gets a bit more praise than it deserves.
on 5/5/2013
Toy Story has the slight edge.
on 1/11/2015
Toy Story may be a landmark film of my childhood, leading to an emotional toll from Toy Story 3, but there's a lot of Toy Story I don't adore as an adult. Fight Club is so, so frustrating because it's quite good and wholly misunderstood. But it is compelling end to end.
Fight Club is a brilliant film but Toy Story tops it.
Buzz and Woody thump Fincher...
Battle of the titans. Both are in my top 5 but fight club by a little.
on 8/6/2015
Toy story is very clever, emotional, funny, and surprisingly dark for a G rated movie. On the other hand, fight club is a suspenseful movie with a good story, a shocking twist, and a great ending ( although toys was arguably even better with that touch of the dog). In the end, I guess I'll give toy story the win with its family- entertainment value, even if fight club was kind of funny. very close call!
on 10/19/2015
On second thought, Toy story doesn't really have the unpredictableness and unique concept within Fight Club. Toy Story is great for a G-rated film and perhaps the BEST, if I were to say, but I don't quite think it can beat the Fight Club of a masterpiece. The plot twist does it for Fight Club, IMO.
on 11/9/2015
Past Me, You are correct. Toy Story is excellent, but Fight Club still wins. I do admit it's close, though.
on 11/11/2019
Toy Story is generation masterpiece, fight club gets beyond overrated in modern times now union times now.
on 3/18/2023
Both sooooooo good but Fight Club for me
on 11/5/2023
If it was Toy Story 2 it would be a little more difficult, but it's easily Fight Club.
