Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
2 comments
5 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 1/17/2011
While Jack Black goes for crude (but effective) laughs on the way to romance, Bill Murray does it right, and displays 10x the emotion and development in the process.
Groundhog Day, It's amazing how they filmed it. The continuity is almost spot on every time, right down to the cars and the distance between the people in the background. I've watched it twice to just look at the background placements
on 11/21/2013
Shallow Hal is actually really good, but Groundhog Day is nigh-unbeatable next to it.
on 5/16/2018
Shallow Hal>Groundhog Day
Groundhog Day was a gem and wins this.
on 4/26/2020
Shallow Hal is complete dog crap and nearly insufferable. Groundhog Day wins with ease!
Groundhog Day by a country mile.
on 4/27/2020
Can't help it...I'm a Shallow Hal guy...