Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
54 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/6/2017
Without question Thor's number three film crushes Rises. Not even a contest. Most people HATED TDKR and it ended what is generally considered by most to be the overrated nolan trilogy on the worst note possible. Whereas Thor's trilogy finished with its best effort.
Of course, Thor comes up significantly short, most intelligent cinephiles agree that Nolan's magnificent trilogy soundly trounces anything else in the CBM genre by quite a large margin and is constantly ranked among the all-time classic threequels (LOTR and Original Star Wars) for too many reasons to count.
on 11/7/2017
Thor delivered the far better trilogy. Not even a contest.
on 7/14/2018
Thor Ragnarok. Though I am a Nolan fan, Thor 3 beats TDKR. However, both Batman Begins and TDK are superior to Thor and Thor 2. So Nolan's TDK trilogy is superior to Thor's.
Thor Ragnarok is that sensational amazing moments more than that flawed Dark Knight Rises is.
About time I weighed in on the Squaremaster vs Marvelites debate. As most would agree, both sides are guilty of rabid fanboyism, but the reason I'd put Square one step above the Marvelites is because it makes sense to be a fan of one author's vision. Square's love of Nolan is unhealthy, fanatical, misguided – all that rings true, but it's defensibly sincere in that it springs from a single consistent source guiding writing, directing, production and other aspects of film-making. When Square sits down to watch a Chris Nolan movie, he can be reasonably sure of enjoying it on account of the shot composition, thematic content, narrative devices and stylization unique to an auteur like Chris Nolan. What's more difficult to understand is how someone can like a film simply because their favorite superhero is in them – and this pretty much sums up the Marvelites' allegiance to MCU. It doesn't matter who the director is, who the writer is, in which direction the story is being taken, whether the film can stand on its own artistic merits or exists just as a cash-grab set-up for bigger projects in the future – all Marvel movies HAVE to be awesome. After a while this kind of loyalty becomes hard to believe, and hard to bear as well, though Square is no saint either.
on 7/15/2018
Ragnarok was great. TDKR sucked to high heaven. Next...
I stated this once and will do so once more: Marvel movies are as deep as a focking puddle. Anyone one who pretends they aren't is in my a view either a troll or a halfwit. These movies only purpose is to sell the cotton candy of cinema to moronic kids. That leaves tdkr unequivocally superior to them.
Thor: Ragnarok is both smart and fun. DKR was about as smart as a first grader and about as fun as an old age home.
on 11/16/2018
Thor Ragnarok was far awesome better trilogy while Dark Knight Rise certainly often failed of a flawed let down of a trilogy but Thor Ragnarok just hammers TDKR in every way, TDKR was far the worst!
on 12/9/2019
Ragnarok is far watchable as it is and while as TDKR isn’t.
on 7/5/2020
why the fuck is rises and joker so damn hated in the website wtf
Maximum watchability vs unproven overrated, Ragnarok easily edged here...
on 8/4/2020
rises isn't overrated wtf you mean it was hated by almost everyone here
The Dark Knight Rises. Better plot, villain, soundtrack, and acting.
I love what Christopher Nolan did with the Dark Knight trilogy but I feel that THOR: RAGNAROK holds together better as a standalone film, not to mention the fact that is is much better than the two films that came before it.
on 8/5/2020
Who even want to consider TDKR will be yet the greatest installment of the franchise mostly forgettable disappointment boring ending, Thor Ragnarok is yet the bestest pure awesomeness of it’s franchise clearly.
on 8/17/2020
Thor Ragnarok admit to be the best third film to the standard MCU, TDKR is generally disappointing ended consuming flawed.
on 9/14/2020
ofc how the fuck do you surpass the dark knight
Above to one of those third films presume to be the best installment which was Thor that didn’t get any flawed with no major cliffhanger off cuts for even more gets it’s goal to achieve films for the greater that has gotten far.
on 9/15/2020
Thor wins...just so much fun....
on 9/29/2020
LOL dude just called ragnarok flawless gtfo
In fact there’s no way that rises is really that far superior anything it competes which far Thor 2 is obviously the far superior rewatchable complete film of the MCU collection saga.
The darker tone of the Dark Knight movies is great, but entertainment-wise it doesn't hold up to the fun and over-the-top Thor Ragnarok
on 9/30/2020
Flaws and all Thor Ragnarok is way better than the crapfest known as Dark Knight Fizzles.
on 10/6/2020
LMAO cxfate called thor 2 the far superior rewatchable lmao don't even
TDKR stomps. These Marvel socks are hilarious, same typing..
Who wants to even care about about the dull bad forgettable rises in this whole way Thor Ragnarok by far.
on 10/7/2020
Thor Ragnarok is gathered to be the funniest best entertainment action of the MCU saga and beyond far superior, the dark knight rises is definitely the worst disappointing of the Nolan trilogy, this is no competition here.
lmao cxfate you thought the dark world is better than rises gtfo
@noobpb17 needs to stop commenting over and over to rises.
on 10/11/2020
at least im using only one account and not like 30 other alts to make rises look bad while repeating the same phrase like a broken record
@noobpb17 is a dumb jerk that needs to stop commenting over and over repeat the same facts about rises is better that anything of marvel of it’s saga franchise.
I really like Thor Ragnarok, it is a really fun and entertaining film that actually made Thor a really likable character. However, The Dark Knight Rises is a superior film. The acting, cinematography, villain, and soundtrack are all better in The Dark Knight Rises. It was a solid conclusion to the Nolan trilogy. Ragnarok is still amazing though.
on 10/12/2020
Why is there anybody go for TDKR, it is just nonsense, Thor Ragnarok is only further far superior.
lol my comments kept getting deleted
AND @Mdimmock63 i literally praised infinity war, iron man 1, spiderman 2, logan, the winter soldier loads and loads of time
while all you do is sit on your computer and comment rises bad with your 1000 different alts with the same phrase over and over
@noobpb17 is a stupid dumb jerk that needs to stop going getting rises gets better and better which would be nonsense call.
on 10/13/2020
Why there are more concerns in here, Thor Ragnarok is way superior imo.
TDKR is incredibly such bad terrible of it’s while way flawed it is.
"anyone who likes rises is big bad cause no agree with me :(((("
How stupid @noobpb17 keeps mounting same and same comments over and over which is getting more generally annoyed frustrating with the whole same matchups that needs to stop.
on 10/14/2020
The Dark Knight Rises ANNIHILATES this stupid piece of shit that even thor 1 and 2 are better than
Thor Ragnarok once more.
There’s even more multiable comments that why people keeps mounting over and over that now it’s getting more annoyed of that, rises is generally far disappointing in every way it is.
on 10/15/2020
Thor Ragnarok is a garbage film that's even worse than Thor 1 and 2 which makes it the worst trilogy ever
Mdimmock63 funny how you're the one talking about "mounting same and same comments" like dude check your history and check how many comments are the same phrase over and over with your alts anytime rises is about to win i bet you're about to spam the dark world vs rises thread praising dark world LOL
Two user people who keep mounting same and same that are so dumb.
on 10/16/2020
lmao using your own alt to make it look like you're innocent
shut the fuck up retarded noob bitchpb17
i want you dead cause you are probably and fat and ugly retard who likes marvel and faps to marvel porn everyday and hate dc
OK NOW WTF DUDE I LITERALLY VOTED FOR RISES IN THIS THREAD WTF DO YOU WANT I DIDN'T HAVE TO VOTE RISES FOR EVERYTHING THERE ARE TONS OF MOVIE BETTER THAN IT ALTHOUGH IT'S GOOD
Two loser stupid idiot voting for one bad forgotten bad film ever of a end trilogy.
Why this keeps being more wasting again and again.
Lol, he commented a bunch of times.
Critics, audience, awards, polls everyone voted for TDKR. Only on this site we have Marvel fanboys making multiple accounts to let their movie win.
on imdb rises has a better rating and votes than every marvel films
also @mdimmock63 im not even voting for the movie im just arguing with that @thecrackers guy who follows me and throws insult at me at every tdkr thread
and also i voted for infinity war and iron man 1 in their thread against tdkr im not biased like you and @thecrackers
on 10/17/2020
Going with marvel always over DC anywhere for sure.
Thor Ragnarok is obviously the best third film of all, TDKR is not.
Rises is still overloaded let down that doesn’t make anything progress good to get the ranking higher here.
Rises is the far underrated film of the saga
We have to agree on that.
We need to agree above Thor Ragnarok is nearly the watchable best third complete film of the standard franchise.
on 10/18/2020
CXFATE JUST CALLED RISES UNDERRATED WTF
or you're just copy and pasting words that you don't even know to sound like an adult
we don't need to agree cause thor ragnarok is a fucking garbage that noobpb17 and krick64 and mazevents and mdimmock63 like to lick on everyday which even thor 1 and 2 is better than this unfunny garbage that doomed thor trilogy
see i cant vote for one movie without the fucking other side trashing on me
ragnarok endLame and trash panther are the overrated worst movies of the mcu
TDKR is terrible in a whole way.
Most of DCEU is overrated junk.
Two annoying people who keep doing commenting over and over.
and you are just one dude using 60000 alts
TRASHnarok is more overrated and even worse than Thor 1 and 2
Ragnarok isn’t trash, rises is trash.
You can’t suggest DCEU is the best among all source ridiculous
You can’t suggest MCU is old of trash
It clearly isn’t, DCEU is load of garbage
on 11/3/2020
Another stupid idiot keeps doing this over and over.
Stop it, little dickhead who has tantrums.
Stop it you piece annoying loser.
TDKR, little piece of shit shut up
Annoying piece of garbage you are
You're a mentally ill piece of shit
Holy shit, you're so pathetic.
on 11/4/2020
I don’t get why he gotta use alts there.
I hope we can have good discussions in the future in this site
on 3/16/2021
Ragnarok is much better than the first two movies and it’s fun, but The Dark Knight Rises is better due to tighter script and a better villain
Sir Jokes-a-lot Thor is not my favorite but is still better than the AWFUL end to the Bat-trilogy. What a let down.
on 3/17/2021
says the one who thinks Superman 3 is better than TDKR
Superman 3 over The Dark Knight Rises?? o_0
well he/she/whatever said that Rises is the worst third installment ever
on 4/8/2021
ragnarok is better than previous garbage thor movies, dark knight rises is the best superhero movie ever, bane is way better than hela
on 4/18/2021
I gotta go with Rises but Thor 3 is good too. I respect your opinion if you think it is overrated. I just find it more thought provoking. Thor 3 is a good gem in the industry though but I consider Rises to be the second best comic book movie ever made so far. Thor 3 is a 9 while Rises is a 10 to me. It gets better every time you watch it. I’d rank it in the middle of the Nolan films.
i used to think ragnarok was overrated back then, but now i look at it. it's probably top 10 mcu films
on 4/27/2021
Dunno why people waste time with Cx or Yellowjacket
on 5/4/2021
I don’t know why Marvel are trying to bring Thor down to his lowest and then spread jokes all over it. That’s not a good combination. This was kinda a prelude to how bad the joke named Thor would be in Endgame. The comedy keeps this story from getting better and is irrelevant to the plot. While the TDKR had jokes that were related to the plot like the “your wife said you were taking a cab home” Bruce: “my wife”? *Catwoman speeds away in his car.
Crap I just realized that the joke I just mentioned doesn’t hold any relevance to the plot so I connect that statement I said about Thor to TDKR.
on 6/29/2021
TDKR is still better, but i really like ragnarok more than ever now
on 6/30/2021
Funny that Ragnarok may be the weakest of the Thor movies yet is still damn good. True fun and leans towards epic. Whereas TDKR is ceratinly the weak tit in that trilogy but it's so bad that it has NO redeeming qualities.
https://comicvine.gamespot.com/forums/gen-discussion-1/better-film-schindlers-list-or-star-wars-episode-i-2111019/ "I vote for ROTJ, which is probably the best trilogy ending ever alongside CW and TDKR." Credits to @noobpb17
Oh shit alright then... Rises wins but Ragnarok is still really fun.
thx for the credit @Supeherofan1
on 7/18/2021
My my this is quite hilarious, one of the best superhero movies against the trash mcu movie that ruined a trilogy
on 10/2/2021
This is actually a tough one. Ragnarok is genius and obviously one of the best MCU films there is. But Dark Knight Rises is just such an incredible and epic film... DKR wins here, but both are in my top 20 (for now).
on 11/6/2021
Two very good films with excellent direction. I could actually change my mind but my love for Nolan's Batman films is hard to beat.
on 4/4/2022
Ragnarok was much better than the first two Thor movies, excited to see what will Taika Watiti do with the fourth film (Honestly the movie is coming in months and still no trailer…) but it doesn’t stand a chance against Nolan’s Batman
on 4/7/2022
Best Thor movie vs. worst Nolan Batman movie. Had it been any other part of the Nolan trilogy I might have had more doubts, but this is a pretty easy call to make for me.
on 4/19/2022
Thor Ragnarok is just uninspired trash, the third comedy to come in a row in 2017
thor ragnarok amazing moments, but dark knight rises has more substantial masterpiece qualities
TDKR is so bad that I honestly think Studios will never give Nolan another big budget to play with.
TDKR, no contest, but hey look at the brighter side, the squaremaster alt/wannabe is back
on 7/16/2022
The Dark Knight Rises is by far the weakest of the Nolan Batman trilogy, but still an entertaining movie. The Thor trilogy isn't great as a whole, but Ragnarok definitely helped end it (until L&T) on a high note.
on 7/25/2022
Ragnarok is a pretty good movie and pretty mature underneath the heaps of comedy, but TDKR is just on an entirely different level.
on 9/19/2022
Thor was decent. Nolan was just.. darn. A whole different level in filmmaking
on 3/10/2023
Thor is an overrated piece of shit
