Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
7 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/11/2012
Pretty hard matchup discussion, for performance Godfather 2 wins out, but for plot and impact I have to give the win to Fight Club. Brad Pitt and Edward Norton it is.
on 3/20/2013
I prefer Fight Club
Both top 20. Fight Club beats the first Godfather, but not the second.
on 2/6/2016
Fight Club 3-2
Fight Club. The Godfather 2 was good, but I can't stand 200 minutes.
on 6/13/2018
Fight Club for me it's such a honorable story.
Godfather II all day. Micheal Corleone's transformation into a soulless mob boss is infinitely more compelling then Tyler Durden's descent in madness or sanity or whatever.
I can appreciate both but I wouldn't call myself a fan of either. Fight Club for me
on 6/14/2018
Fight Club is that good to win here.
on 9/11/2022
The Godfather Part 2 by quite a big margin. It's a better story. Fight Club is glorious and a sharply written satire, but it really doesn't hold up by comparison
on 12/27/2022
fight club is one of my all-time favorites but the godfather part 2 is a way more powerful film
