Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
19 comments
12 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/9/2009
The best Godfather beats the best LOTR by far...
on 10/13/2010
Two great epic films here the third Lord of the Rings film is an outstanding in just about every way but I prefer The Godfather Part II, I just love every minute of that film.
LOTR wins for me.
The second best Godfather rapes the worst LOTR.
on 7/17/2011
I don't know. I love the godfather part II, but i just don't think it's as good as everyone says. When i think of return of the king, i always think of the extended edition, which is much better. and yet, the godfather is better. can't deny it.
on 2/5/2012
The Godfather Pt II was better than Return of the King. Period.
on 2/6/2012
The Godfather Pt II emerges victorious
on 3/16/2012
The Godfather wins out. I enjoyed it a lot.
on 7/9/2012
The right answer is The Godfather: Part II.
on 11/11/2012
Hyman Roth should team up with Sauron.
on 2/3/2013
Part II is a more complete experience.
Return of the King destroys part II even if it was part I i would have no problem choosing a winner.
on 4/7/2013
I'm with 'MrAwesome245'...If it were the original Godfather film, I would go against the King but I found the Godfather Part II surprisingly disappointing compared with the masterpiece the original is...I'm really surprised as to why the sequel is considered the better film
Both are in my top 10 of all time (7 and 9). The Godfather Part II barely wins this.
on 5/13/2013
Well compared to the first Godfather, any movie would be a disappointment. But many regard TGF2 as superior to part 1 although i don't think so. But i liked FOTR a lot more than ROTK. It introduces us to the story in a grand manner, it had better sceneries, less cheap CGI heavy overlong battle sequences plus its a lot shorter. Not that ROTK wasn't great but honestly i didn't like the new characters that much & the ending scenes just seemed to go on & on. TGF2 is much better obviously.
So close...but Return of the King wins. Reserve the right to change my mind...
A legendary classic (TGF2) versus an epic blockbuster (ROTK). Can I be honest with you? I simply enjoyed ROTK more than TGF2. ROTK is my favorite of the LOTR trilogy. Smeagol/Gollum was outstanding. He was my favorite character of the entire trilogy. At the end of the day, I could probably count on one hand the number of movies I enjoyed more than the LOTR trilogy.
I'm with 'Nononsense' I just find the entire LOTR trilogy better than The Godfather "PART II" Still love Part II but it isn't as important to me as LOTR. Against the original Godfather film, ROTK and TTT would easily lose
on 6/25/2013
The Godfather, Part II crushes here.
Both are still in my top 10, but Return of the King is now higher.
LOTR was a worthy conclusion to a very good series, but The Godfather 2 is one of the great achievements of the American cinema.
on 8/16/2013
Return of the King is my favourite movie of all time so....
on 12/29/2013
part II
on 1/2/2014
Return of the King
on 5/8/2014
LOTR was always be my best film of all
Godfather Part II
on 1/9/2017
LOTT
I mean LOTR
on 1/11/2017
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King
on 3/28/2019
I've definitely watched RotK more and would rate the LotR series higher, but Godfather II stands by itself as a great movie. RotK sorta requires the other two to fully appreciate.
on 7/5/2021
ROTK was an hour longer and was still more entertaining and better paced than Godfather 2.
on 9/23/2022
Both super epic, but The Godfather is better
on 9/24/2022
My third and fourth favorite movies ever, The Godfather Part II, both are masterpieces
on 1/25/2023
If it was The Godfather ROTK would lose but since it is part 2...
