Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
27 comments
22 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/12/2009
Taratino's best. Basterds was just a tad better to me.
on 1/15/2010
I hate to do it because I love Reservoir Dogs, but Inglourious Basterds is the tighter, more rewatchable movie.
on 2/18/2010
Yeah, the more I think about it, the more it becomes clear that Basterds is my favorite Tarantino. It might be because I'm German, actually...
on 2/27/2010
I agree with all of the previous comments, and that these are Tarantino's best.
on 4/6/2010
Ooohhh... So tough decision... But I think I go with Basterds here... It was sublime.
on 4/7/2010
Uh, wow. Going with Reservoir Dogs. Though IB is easily more rewatchable.
on 4/15/2010
Basterds for me, hands down. I think it just might be QT's masterpiece ;)
on 7/1/2010
Best!? Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill Vol. 1 are my favorites. Here I think I'll go with Basterds, cause there's a little more substance to the characters and it's cinematically prettier.
Basterds by a photo finish.
on 3/23/2011
Fuck, this is a hard decision. I'll say Basterds, today.
on 5/8/2011
Really, REALLY, tough decision. Gotta go with Reservoir Dogs, though. It's still the first thing I think of when I think Tarantino.
on 11/15/2011
Both are incredible, two of Tarantino's best (but aren't they all, really?) But since this is so close I got simply on which I found more entertaining and which is more rewatchable and if I'm picking a movie to watch right now out of these two, I'm gonna go with Inglourious Basterds.
on 1/7/2012
Reservoir Dogs is the better movie to me, but just by a hair.
I'll go with Bastards...and for me, it's not that close...
on 1/8/2012
Reservoir Dogs.
on 1/22/2012
Reservoir Dogs is Tarantino's best movie till date.
on 2/19/2012
Reservoir dogs for now.
on 4/10/2012
Basterds for me, but a case could be made for either.
on 6/5/2012
Basterds was painfully slow.Of course Brad's bad acting didn't help its cause.Dogs wins it easy.
Reservoir Dogs. Tarantino's best.
on 7/1/2012
#1 vs. #9
on 7/6/2012
Both are great Tarantino films, but Basterds edges a little
on 7/7/2012
I think Basterds is Tarantino's second best behind Pulp Fiction, so that wins.
on 7/10/2012
Dogs had a tight story unlike Basterds which was all over the place. There's no beating the 90's Tarantino. Sorry IB. QT will never top the simplicity and brilliance of RD.
on 11/23/2012
Reservoir Dogs for sure. The dialogue is one of the best I've ever seen in film history and the performances are awesome. Inglourious Basterds lacked cohesion in some areas and didn't hold up until the end, that being said Reservoir Dogs was airtight until it climaxed.
on 1/27/2013
I could teeter totter between the two, but Basterds, probably because I've never seen anyone give history a middle finger and rewrite it the way they wanted to and get away with it.
Two of the greatest films of all time from my favorite director, Basterds has the slight edge.
on 2/1/2013
#TeamReservoir.
on 2/11/2013
Resevoir Dogs obviously
on 3/6/2013
The Basterds is a more finely tuned experience compared to The Dogs and Fiction (which some consider to be the pinnacle of Tarantino's career).
on 3/11/2013
I love all Tarantino movies I've seen yet (that includes Pulp Fiction, Reservoir Dogs, Kill Bill Vol 1 and 2, Django Unchained) but the only one I didn't like was Inglorious Basterds which lacked the brilliance that all other QT movies have to me. Reservoir Dogs is placed at 10 and is just amazing to watch. Perfect characters, amazing dialogue and just an amazingly executed story
on 4/9/2013
Inglourious is glorious.
on 6/18/2013
Wow, this is a matchup...
on 7/15/2013
For now I'm gonna have to switch over to The Dogs.
IB was my first Tarantino movie. RD was my second. Both are amazing, but I think I prefer the simplicity of RD.
Reservoir Dogs
on 9/13/2013
Basterds was a bit better for me as well, not by much though.
on 9/17/2013
Tough choice,very tough. But I'm going with Basterds. It's so exhilarating,intense,fun, and entertaining. Reservoir Dogs is one of my favorites as well.
Both are probably Tarantino's two greatest films after Pulp Fiction (my opinion). Reservoir Dogs is superior.
on 9/28/2013
Reservoir Dogs is my 2nd favorite Tarantino flick. Basterds is amazing though
on 4/12/2014
Reservoir Dogs takes it
on 12/6/2014
Interesting... early vs. late Tarantino... Inglorious Basterds shows his maturity as a director
on 9/5/2015
Basterds has Hans Landa and Natzis.
on 3/31/2016
I'm honestly now taking Inglourious Basterds. A perfect movie in almost every regard, and somehow Tarantino stretches the opening 20 minutes of suspense (the rat and hawk speech) into a 150 minute movie. It's thrilling from opening moment to last, without even the slightest exaggeration, as is Reservoir Dogs, but IB has a few more standout sequences for my taste.
on 7/4/2016
Reservoir Dogs has more originality
on 11/25/2016
Inglorious Basterds is Tarantino's second best
on 5/23/2018
Dogs rules against Basterds.
on 7/6/2020
Gots to go with Dogs! It's style and tight structure just has always stuck with me more.
on 9/12/2021
Both are good. I can't really choose. But if I must, Inglorious Basterds it is, for the more complexity of the plot and better cinematography
on 4/25/2022
Possibly my two favorite Tarantino movies, but I prefer Reservoir Dogs
on 11/1/2022
Loved both, but Reservoir Dogs is definitely the better movie here
