Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
3 comments
7 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/20/2009
Tough one! Greece, weddings....I think Mamma Mia! wins, though, it's got singing.
on 5/9/2010
The lesser of two evils for me...
Mamma Mia! was My Big Fat Wedding a fiasco.
on 8/18/2010
Wow, battle of the Greek-themed romances. I'm going with Big Fat Wedding just because Pierce Brosnan singing is a little bit grating on the ears.
on 5/13/2011
My wife has made me watch Mamma Mia! three times so far. I've actually managed to stomach it all three times, despite Brosnan's singing. I don't think I could ever sit through My Big Fat Greek Wedding again. Fortunately, I don't think my wife cared for it that much, either.
on 2/9/2012
I wonder why I have seen both of these movies... I shouldn't have...
on 4/4/2012
My Big Fat Greek Wedding has a more heartfelt story than Mammia Mia, which seemed to be made merely as an excuse to sing a bunch of ABBA (which is fun, but certain stars really shouldn't sing on screen *coughPierceBrosnancough*). The former also has a good ending and is funnier.
on 9/7/2012
Oh dear. Hate both, but I had the misfortune of watching Mamma Mia in the cinema, with no chance of escape. Plus I did actually laugh once or twice in MBFGW, so I'll go with the ridiculously profitable Greek wedding.
on 3/24/2016
Mama Mia! Was better IMO. The only funny scene in MBFGW was the line "I have three testicles".
on 8/19/2018
My wife absolutely loves Mamma Mia.....but she isn't the one voting here.