The Treasure of the Sierra Madre vs. The Maltese Falcon

7 comments

4 comments

on 11/26/2012

Hell yeah, two of Humphrey Bogart's very best. The Treasure of the Sierra Madre wins because, well, it's pretty much a masterpiece.

on 11/26/2012

Sierra Madre. I actually find The Falcon to be a huge letdown...

on 2/16/2013

i loved both, but sierra madre is better

on 2/17/2013

Not let down for me. The Falcon was everything I had hoped.

on 2/28/2014

Two greats from Huston and Bogart. Sierra Madre had a more satisfying ending and was just better overall.

on 2/28/2014

The Maltese wins!

on 3/1/2014

Sierra Madre.

on 3/1/2014

The 1940's were the decade of Bogart. Two unbelievable films. Does not matter which you choose in this matchup. You are right either way.

on 9/20/2015

Definitely one of the closest matchups as the winner could easily change. For now it goes to Treasure.

on 9/20/2015

Madre is good but Falcon is easily my pick.

on 6/5/2018

I think Sierra Madre is Bogart’s best performance, but Falcon is the better film.