Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
5 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 5/3/2011
Fellowship is easily the best of the LOTR films and also one of my favourite films evr. Still, Toy Story is more important to me, whatever the fuck that means.
on 1/30/2013
It means it's fucking important. Nostalgia, man.
on 9/2/2013
I Love both, but not much can beat Lord of the Rings.
14 and 15 on my list. Reach for the sky!
*14 and 16
on 5/4/2014
TS by far, oh I mean FOTR by far :)
on 2/28/2015
Every Toy Story Film > Every Lord of the Rings Film
on 6/14/2015
ARGGGHHHHHH!!!!! NOOOOOOOOO!!! Let's take a closer look at these two--TS has a surprising amount of development considering its time frame compared to The Ring. While it's funnier and arguably even cleverer than The Ring, the ring adds more twists, even to one who has read the book [which I have]. While The Ring's ending does not go anywhere in particular, hinting that there was really no tension-climax, the amount of tension in total evens it out quite well, even compared to TS's hilarious, satisfying ending. Well, since Toy Story is number 6 on my flickchart, and I don't have time for analyzing these two further, I'll just choose the Pixar + Disney masterpiece...for now. I might re-rank The Ring later with a more detailed analysis of the two films.
Fellowship takes this
on 10/1/2017
Toy Story is one of the most important films of the last 25 years. And I grew up watching it over and over. It's been too long since I've seen any LotR movies, but for now, Toy Story is the winner.
Toy Story for me pretty clearly. I remember when I was watching it at 16, Lord of the Rings just seemed to go on and on. I've been meaning to rewatch it, now that I'm older and have more patients, bui Toy Story for me is the better movie.
on 10/2/2017
Toy Story. LOTR, to me, is the most overrated movie of all time. In fact, I find it unbearable to sit through!
on 7/20/2018
Toy Story is far decent but it can't beat LotR: Fellowship in my opinion..
on 9/5/2018
Lord of the Rings over the toys..
on 7/23/2021
Toy Story beats Lord of the Rings for me, not just for this battle but as a whole.
