Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/9/2012
Surprised that there are no comments on this.
on 10/11/2012
Well, why would anyone comment about a lopsided matchup like this?
Sorry Hitch.
on 9/3/2013
I'm really not sure which to pick...They're very different and very good...
Gotta go Psycho.
Mulholland DR. which is more hypnotic and more interesting.
on 11/18/2013
Psycho was a really great movie, but I have to go with Mulholland Dr. It just has a lot more going on.
on 2/19/2015
Psycho pummels Mulholland Dr.
on 10/22/2018
Both movies, despite the televisual origins of their productions, boldly confront the darker aspects of sexual identity in a consummately cinematic fashion. Hitchcock and Lynch, the remarkably unapologetic artists they are, don't shy away from taking on controversial or experimental material, a prerequisite for making films like Psycho, Blue Velvet, and Mulholland Drive. Close call but in the end I'll take Mulholland Drive due to my utter distaste for black-and-white films.
David Lynch? Verbal reasoning is not his thing. That is why his films end up being aberrant and perplexing.
