Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
0 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 10/21/2011
Dang, now here's the real match-up! Probably the two best DCAU movies out there. I have to go with "Year One" though, it captured the feel of the original story almost dead on.
on 10/27/2011
Sounds like a recommendation to me.
on 2/10/2013
Year one was good but it didn't have enough of batman in it.I get that it's more of Gordian's story then batman but i personally would rather see more batman.Red hood wins here.
on 8/3/2013
I really think both of these movies are interesting and involving Batman stories that show what the DC Original Showcase has to offer. However, I think Under the Red Hood works more as it own movie. While I think Year One just simply adapts it to screen, also I feel the movie is more Gordon's story than Batman's. So, I think Red Hood is the winner in this match.
I really liked both, but Under the Red Hood was better.
on 1/31/2015
Under the Red Hood was way better. Talk about ballsy.
on 8/17/2016
Under the Red Hood
on 7/19/2020
Yeah, Under the Red Hood is better. It's funny, Under the Red Hood comes off like an improved Mask of the Phantasm to me, while Year One feels like a discount Batman Begins. Obviously, the one that improves upon a similarly solid story wins.
