Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
10 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 6/19/2015
If Inside Out had been longer and dealt with the emotions of her parents and others around her more, it might have a chance at besting the Incredibles. But The Incredibles succeeds at having full, satisfying character arcs for, well, practically every last one of it's characters. Inside Out can't compete with that.
on 6/25/2015
Inside Out, very close though
On second thought, and after seeing it twice more, Inside Out takes it here. It feels like a culmination of Pixar's entire filmography to me. It just has it all, including the best character animation I've seen from Pixar, or from any animated movie for that matter. There are better Pixar films, yes, but The Incredibles isn't one of them. Not quite.
on 6/26/2015
Incredibles is far, far, far, far, far better.
on 6/30/2015
The Incredibles. Both are great though.
on 7/20/2015
Inside Out, although Incredibles was very good and its cliffhanger ending was simply amazing. I await for the sequel.
on 8/1/2015
Incredibles cause more action
Inside Out struck a more significant chord with me....
on 8/9/2015
Shit, really? Inside Out's trailer paints it as a witty film that's slightly off-centre. The film, however, is anything but. There's the odd bit of charming repartee, but it's hidden in a fog of middling cheese (and I use the word 'middling' very deliberately; Inside Out is very much an on-centre movie). It's an OK film, but it's got nowt on The Incredibles.
on 9/3/2016
The Incredibles wins this one!
on 1/9/2017
Both amazing Pixar films, but Inside Out wins easily. The Incredibles is boring.
Inside Out wins lots of awards in any kinds of categories, like the Best Animated Feature of the Year.
on 1/31/2017
Inside Out
on 6/19/2017
mcgratha's cheating so NO CAPES!
NO CAPES!
NO CAPES! And that should be enough comments to counter mcgratha's comment cheating
on 8/30/2017
Would anybody like to have a pizza roll?
on 5/8/2019
The Incredibles is fine but I find it kinda empty. Inside Out is not just a colourful film with plenty of laughs but it has a lot of heart and left questions about the importance of our emotions and background that I've thinking about days after watching it!
on 9/30/2019
I'm going with The Incredibles by far
on 3/21/2022
Inside Out might have won this if it weren't for the plot. The plot holes are too egregious to ignore. If it weren't for that, Inside Out would be perfect. It's so emotional, so mature for a kids movie, so intelligent and complex in conveying emotion, so hilarious, and so enjoyable. But as it stands, The Incredibles is more complete.
