Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
14 comments
9 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 9/4/2009
This choice kept me here for a while. But I've got to go with The Godfather. But this was practically a flip of the coin.
on 11/4/2009
These very well could be the two greatest crime movies ever. But... you never go against family.
on 12/5/2009
Yeah, i agree with both of you this is a real tough one, both amazing movies, but Godfather is king
on 2/8/2010
I've always thought The Godfather was over long -- over hyped -- and overrated. The Departed is punchy, and hip. The Departed wins.
on 3/25/2010
The Departed is great, but I love Goodfellas more. Win goes to The Godfather.
on 4/11/2010
I've only seen The Godfather once and The Departed a handful of times, so I'm giving this to The Godfather for now.
on 9/12/2010
The Departed is tremendous but The Godfather is a masterpiece.
on 10/1/2010
GOAT
The Departed is the only gangster movie I've seen that I can say I genuinely love.
on 10/2/2010
shibadou said everything that needs to be said. Depahted FTW.
on 4/7/2012
Another big match up. The GF.
on 5/7/2012
Both masterpieces. Ill give this one to Coppola though.
on 10/8/2012
Aaah...crap. The Godfather.
on 11/26/2012
The Godfather for sure. Departed lacked in some areas.
on 11/27/2012
I will go with the Godfather but not by much.
on 12/31/2012
The Departed is a more complete movie in my opinion.
on 5/4/2013
best movie ever.
on 1/10/2014
the godfather was original and it's timeless masterpiece .I can't say the same for the departed still a great film
The Departed is an excellent film and my favourite Scorcese film to date, but it still can't compete with The Godfather.
on 5/29/2014
The Godfather
on 4/23/2015
Godfather is great. Departed is better.
on 10/24/2015
The departed is far better movie.I like Godfather but it is a bit boring at parts(yes it is and we all know that,but don't agree) and has some unnecessary sequenses that should have been edited out.I still like it.It's a treasure trove of outstanding performances.But it can't match with Scorsese's greatest IMO
on 3/17/2018
The Godfather is a masterpiece, but in this one The Departed always gets much better to watch again and again sorry Vito Corleone but i can't refuse to the brillant scenes and kills in The Departed and for that my preference is The Departed
on 7/20/2022
The Departed is awesome, but yeah The Godfather easily takes this
on 10/2/2022
Godfather without a doubt.
on 11/16/2022
I love the departed by the godfather set the standard for crime movies.
on 7/7/2023
The Godfather is one of the weakest gangster movies in my opinion