Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
39 comments
29 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 12/28/2009
These are probably the best of the genre but i would have to go with Pulp fiction
on 4/9/2010
Yeah, I find Pulp Fiction far more entertaining, and one of those movies I could watch again and again. Can't say the same for The Godfather, at least not yet.
on 1/6/2011
I can't decide. I can't decide. I can't decide.
on 1/18/2011
I pick pulp fiction just because i can watch it over and over.
on 4/23/2011
There cannot be better crime movies. And PULP is so originally told, and so entertaining. But GODFATHER just sets up house in your head and dares you to evict it. And you're OK with that (I am, anyway).
The Godfather is a classic among classics.
No film is as entertaining as The Godfather.
on 4/28/2011
I pick the movie that's more entertaining, and that's Pulp Fiction.
on 7/2/2011
The IMDB match off. Funny thing is, they arn't in my top 10 movie list. They're just both averagelly there for everyone. Pulp FIction is funnier.
Very tough battle...but I'll go with the Godfather by the tiniest of margins...
on 12/14/2011
Godfather by a huge margin for me. Pulp Fiction was entertaining, but I never fell in love with it like a lot of people seem to have. I fell in love with The Godfather the first time I saw it.
on 12/17/2011
Pulp Fiction wins this one for sure. The Godfather is a miserable gangster movie, I realy had great expectations for this movie, but then it turned out to be a bad movie with both bad story and bad acting, and there was not any action nor excitement, not even at the shooting scenes, and the movie was TOO boring and lengthy. Godfather can only be discouraged.
I was disappointed by the hype of The Godfather. Although it is a great film and stands the test of time as being one of the best, it just doesn't have the acting or the mesmerizing writing that Pulp Fiction does.
on 1/23/2012
The Godfather owns Pulp Fiction in every single department.
on 2/6/2012
The Godfather wins here
on 2/16/2012
The Godfather is too good to beat. Pulp is good but it doesnt measure up to the Godfather.
on 12/9/2012
The Godfather for sure. It does own in almost every single department.
on 2/3/2013
This isn't hard for me (and I really love Pulp Fiction).
on 2/5/2013
I'm going Pulp Fiction. The Godfather is great, but not in my top 5 like Pulp Fiction.
on 2/6/2013
Pulp by a small margin.
on 3/9/2013
Don't get me wrong, my two favorite crime movies but Pulp Fiction is quite easily the winner for me: Tarantino's dialogue and directing never gets old, neither does any of the stories presented here in what is, perhaps, the greatest film of the 1990's and one of the greatest movies of the 20th Century...Which easily makes this one of the greatest movies ever made! That isn't to say that the Godfather isn't, heck its deserving of the greatest movie of all time but I just enjoy Pulp Fiction a tad more! Btw, both are in my top 10!
on 4/12/2013
Godfather all day for me. Haven't even gotta think about it.
Allow me to break the tie. Godfather simply outclasses Pulp Fiction. Godfather's tone is more serious than Pulp's. And with the nature of these types of movies, a more serious tone is far more appropriate in my opinion. I do enjoy and appreciate the laughs in Pulp though. And don't get me wrong, I love Pulp's cinematography. It rivals the all time greats. But in the end, Godfather's plot and character development are superior to Pulp's.
on 4/19/2013
The Godfather for me, easily. Pulp Fiction was good fun but no way even close to The Godfather.The Godfather sets the limit to how good a movie can be. Most movies compete at its half level and Pulp Fiction doesn't even come among the best in that even.
on 5/4/2013
PF is great TGF is the greatest.
Very tough. Very different. I'm not too sure which I prefer; Godfather was great but not very ambitious whereas Pulp Fiction was a complete breath if fresh air
on 5/12/2013
Sorting through my top 20 is SO HARD!
on 5/15/2013
I found some portions of pulp pointless & boring. Yeah it is innovative & all, but i would have enjoyed it more at about half hours shorter. Godfather beats it in every categories.
on 5/28/2013
The Godfather is the better gangster flick but Pulp Fiction is the more entertaining film. That being said I will give the win to The Godfather by a whisker.
on 6/6/2013
Very hard but i have to go with pulp fiction
on 6/20/2013
Sorry Pulp Fiction, there’s no chance of you winning against the ultimate crime masterpiece which is The Godfather.
on 6/28/2013
The Godfather left me more impressed than Pulp Fiction did.
on 8/9/2013
The Godfather.
on 9/4/2013
The Godfather wins for it's seriousness and better character development. But both are amazing. The Godfather is the ultimate gangster movie. Pulp Fiction would beat any thing else, though.
on 9/9/2013
PULP FICTION. Easy as hell.
on 9/10/2013
When you think about it, this could be the hardest choice of all time in terms of importance to cinema. The answer to this question, at least in my opinion, is Pulp Fiction. Heres the difference-maker: You can be in any mood and enjoy Pulp Fiction. To enjoy The Godfather, you have to be in that sort of mood. It's sorta hard to explain, but you have to feel like watching it. With Pulp, you can turn it on any day at any moment and enjoy the hell out of it. That's why the answer to this question is Pulp Fiction.
on 12/28/2013
Sorry Godfather but it's Pulp Fiction the choice
As entertaining Pulp Fiction might be it will never ever reach the greatness of The Godfather. The Godfather stands the test of time as one of the greatest films in cinema history, an epic story of family,crime, and power.
on 3/15/2014
Both gangster films but different sides of the genre Pulp is almost a parody its bloody and funny but The Godfater set the standerd and drugged you into its real and you cared about the characters like family its a saga with amazing sets and crazy good acting its a icon of masterpieces.
on 3/30/2014
The Godfather Stands The Test of Time as the greatest movie ever made
Pulp Fiction all the way for me
Oh no you didn't! The Godfather has to take this one.
on 10/1/2014
The Godfather
on 4/29/2015
Both are Classic films but yes Pulp Fiction is better.
Godfather > Anything Tarantino ever made.
on 4/30/2015
While both are in my top ten, this one is no contest, Pulp Fiction is the greatest movie ever made!
on 7/18/2015
Pulp Fiction for me. Love them both.
Pulp fiction takes it .
on 7/23/2015
Good one. It depends on the mood you are feeling and the significance. I'll go with Pulp Fiction;
on 11/7/2015
I change my decision, the godfather for the victory
on 11/8/2015
Both great films, but clearly The Godfather
on 3/30/2017
As far as cinematic history goes, both are going to be remembered for a long time. But as quality goes, the Godfather is a near flawless piece of criminal grandeur whereas - and I'm going to be incredibly controversial here - I personally think Pulp Fiction is overrated. Still a great film... But one of the best of all time? Not even close.
on 3/17/2018
Pulp Fiction is more interesting to watch again, but always i was think in my mind than The Godfather is still better than Pulp Fiction
I prefer Pulp Fiction but The Godfather has more powerful acting performances.
Pulp Fiction is great movie,but The Godfather is the best.
on 5/10/2018
The Godfather definitely...
on 5/11/2018
The Godfather easily
on 9/19/2018
I switched to Pulp Fiction.
on 9/20/2018
Neither did anything for me. Godfather at least was serious, coherent, well written and somewhat meaningful enough
Pulp Fiction = Good ... The Godfather = Legendary ... see the difference?
Pulp Fiction is more splendid, I like The Godfather much but I rather go with Pulp Fiction.
on 5/18/2019
Pulp fiction is More entertaining but godfather is better made movie I quess
on 7/9/2019
I enjoy both movies, but I enjoy The Godfather more. I do enjoy both, don't get me wrong, but The Godfather just has so much more character and allows you to invest more into the story it tells.
on 7/27/2019
Both are amazing and landmark films, but I'm gonna go with The Godfather, its my all time favorite movie.
on 8/29/2019
I definitely enjoy both classic films but while pulp fiction has my biggest great effort here.
on 11/13/2019
The godfather.
on 2/24/2020
Godfather.
on 7/16/2020
I am going with Godfather here.
on 7/17/2020
Pulp Fiction is one of my favorites, but the Godfather is way better
on 10/7/2020
Okay, after watching both of these fairly recently I will say that The Godfather is technically a better movie in terms of the acting, the plot, the score, and the cinematography. But Pulp Fiction is WAY more entertaining and I like the characters more. So, I will vote for Pulp Fiction.
on 1/19/2021
Two incredible classics, but The Godfather left more of an impression on me.
on 6/29/2021
godfather by a hair, both top 10 movies of all time
on 8/7/2022
Pulp Fiction is million times better and more awesome than that boring shity Godfather. Godfather is the most overrated movie ever and sucks like hell. Godfather is so boring and slow as a snail, and wooden acting as well. Godfather is a horrible shity movie. The winner is easily Pulp Fiction.
on 11/6/2022
both are good but I liked pulp fiction a bit more close
on 12/3/2022
Pulp fiction lose. The godfather is the best mafia/crime movie of all times
on 1/26/2023
I probably would want to watch Pulp Fiction now but this isn't even close
on 4/12/2023
Pulp fiction is more than a masterpiece for films in general but theres no film out there better than the godfather.
