Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
13 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/12/2009
Are you kidding me? Wall-E vs. Star Wars!?!?!?!?
on 7/17/2009
Hard choice, but I have to go with the classic
on 9/17/2009
I kind of hate the way Star Wars gets so much popularity and I really enjoyed Wall-E, but I think overall I'm going to have to go with Star Wars. Wall-E is a brilliant film, but Star Wars is a part of my up bringing.
on 11/1/2009
Wall-E has nothing to Star Wars. There's no way Wall-E can win.
on 1/9/2010
Pixar endeared me to Wall-E with essentially no dialogue. George Lucas' abominable script endeared me to no one. Wall-E.
on 4/18/2010
As a film, Wall-E is better, I have to say. But as a classic, Star Wars wins. But do you go for the better film or the one you have fond memories of? I think Wall-E wins this round.
on 7/15/2010
I suspect that as time goes on and generations pass this decision will become easier as we are becoming less and less attached to Star Wars, but for me Wall-E actually has the better memories. Star Wars was great, but it didn't blow me away or affect like Wall-E did.
on 9/20/2010
Star Wars is popcorn fun, but Wall-E moved me.
There's nothing wrong with nostalgia; it wins many matchups for me. But in this case, I have such a love for Pixar, and I am so falling out of love with Star Wars, that this is an easy choice.
on 12/10/2010
both movies in space, both have cute robots, wall-e wins in my books
on 8/10/2011
Even as a "Star Wars" fan, I've never been entirely in love with this specific movie. "WALL-E" was surprisingly charming and thoughtful. It gets the nod.
on 11/12/2011
Wall-E can beat any star wars movie, even Empire
on 3/19/2012
Star Wars. I love both of these Sci-Fi legends.
on 4/8/2012
Can you hate both?
on 6/2/2013
Star Wars. Not hating on Wall-E....Star Wars is just too good...
Star Wars. Wall-E is a great movie, but a little overrated in my opinion.
on 6/7/2013
It's like a silent film, don't you get it? He's got sad eyes instead of saying things like "I'm sad!" yeah ok.
on 7/12/2014
wall-e teaches a message and the beginning is absolutely eerie...it wins.
on 4/18/2015
Star Wars is thrilling popcorn entertainment. Wall-E sends you with a bold message claiming that love, friendship and art is what defines humanity.
on 6/30/2015
Star Wars. (Sorry, Pixar.)
on 11/15/2015
No discussion necessary.
Wall.e sucked more
on 4/22/2017
Star Wars is overrated. WALL-E is so much more better.
on 1/12/2018
Two of the greatest sci-fi films ever, but dammit if Wall-E didn't crack my heart open.
on 7/18/2018
Much as for me WALL-E is one of the best pixar films as it is, while for me Star Wars the original is beyond overrated for me..
on 9/20/2022
Loved both movies. Star Wars is great. It has great characters and a great visual style that stands out. But WALL-E is my all time favorite film so it wins here. But I still love Star Wars.
