American History X vs. Inglourious Basterds

10 comments

8 comments

thats funny

ear
ear

X marks the spot.

Funny, but false in this case! Basterds all the way.

ear
ear

These were both great movies but Edward Norton floored me with his powerfully emotional and perfect performance in American History X.

Basterds wins by miles!

The Basterds win, but not by a lot.

I think I prefer the one were the Nazis get killed.

AHX by a nose.

Inglourious basterds is funnyers awesomer and better.

The X has it. Nothing in Basterds can compete with the curb stomp...

X wins because of the depth and performances. Basterds was good fun and well done but ultimately cartoonish.

Who knew Nazis could be so much fun?

AHX felt gritty and real, IB felt like fanfiction.

Both are amazing with brilliant performances, but The Basterds rarely lose.

Inglourious Basterds takes it.

Two movies with Nazis. Gotta pick AMX here.

Both have amazing performances from Norton and Waltz. Tarantino's epic wins.

This is a very, very close one. But AHX hit me harder than almost every other movie ever (didn't make me cry or anything, but that was one striking movie).