Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 3/26/2013
Two of the greatest Christmas films ever made. While 'It's a Wonderful Life' is iconic for it's brilliance, I'll have to go with 34th Street. A perfect screenplay and such atmosphere. Always gets me in the spirit of the season.
How has no one ever commented on these films before now? Still the best two Christmas efforts of all-time. Have to vote Capra!
on 9/28/2013
The two greatest Christmas movies of all-time. Jimmy Stewart is remarkable, and ultimately, his performance is incredible and unforgettable. Maureen O'Hara and young Natalie Wood are both wonderful in Miracle, but the warmth and heart in It's a Wonderful Life is second to none.
on 12/15/2014
How does this matchup only have 3 total votes?
34th street
on 12/16/2014
Two Christmas classics. Both are must watches every holiday season but It's a Wonderful Life is the winner.
on 1/2/2015
Both of these are great movies and they both cause a swelling of emotion for me at the end. It's a Wonderful Life is not really a Christmas movie. So if this matchup is asking which is the better Christmas movie I'd have to say Miracle on 34th St. However, It's a Wonderful Life is a better overall movie.
Absolutely no contest...
on 1/14/2016
Miracle is very good, but IAWL is a masterpiece. IAWL wins for me.
on 12/17/2016
It's a Wonderful by far. I love both, but IAWL is in another league
Jimmy Stewart elevates everything!
on 12/25/2018
49 minutes until Christmas is over :(
Miracle on 34th Street>It's A Wonderful Life
Ho Ho Ho...Merry Christmas world!
on 2/28/2019
Whoa! What a match-up! Both films are great but I find Miracle on 34th Street the easier choice.
on 12/25/2020
Almost 10 hours into Christmas :)
St. Joseph over St. Nicolas !!!
on 11/27/2022
The best movie of all time vs The Cheap Christmas classic. It's not cheap but it's cheap in this matchup, Anyway It's a Wonderful Life>Miracle on 34th Street
