Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
3 comments
1 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 5/10/2012
Two good children's books turned into two mediocre film adaptations. I remember next to nothing about Lemony Snicket. That said, what I recall of Chronicles is more negative than good. Lemony wins for just being blandly forgettable.
on 5/11/2012
I thought that The Chronicles of Narnia was a satisfying interpretation and it's my choice, but I agree that the more it tried to be The Lord of the Rings the closer it got to mediocrity. Concerning Lemony Snicket, there is nothing particularly wrong about it however it lacked a certain spark that I cannot quite identify.
on 4/3/2013
both are somewhat underrated, but lemony snicket is actually thoroughly enjoyable
on 10/26/2018
Narnia is a magical masterpiece
