Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
7 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 9/7/2010
I don't know what to do with this. Both of these movies are some of Pixar's best work. So much emotion, such great characters and stories to tell...but if I must pick one, I'll choose Toy Story 3 for wrapping up the series so well.
on 10/25/2010
Oh god! Why must I choose?! I hate you, FlickChart, I hate you!
on 10/26/2010
I just don't understand why everyone is so blown away by Toy Story 3. It wasn't THAT great; it could've been better. Just to spite all of the people who don't shut up about the third installment, I'm going to choose WALL-E because it was practically ignored.
on 12/12/2010
I'm not that big a fan of Wall.E so this is easy.
on 1/8/2011
A part of me agrees with Fiction_Fox. I DO think it's a great movie, but people have been saying it's a masterpiece and it should be the first animated film to win a Best Picture oscar and all these other things. I really enjoyed the film but rank many other Pixar films ahead of it, including its two predecessors. And including Wall-E. Maybe I just need to watch it again? I'll give it a second viewing soon and perhaps I'll feel stronger about the film. But what I got out of it was really nothing I didn't get out of the previous two, in fact the other two films moved me more. Again, I'll give it another watch. And here I am talking about a Pixar matchup after I promised myself I wouldn't because I very easily change my mind when it comes to their films. *Sigh
on 11/8/2011
Toy Story 3 was awesome, and a great way to end the trilogy (hopefully it really is the end...), but WALL-E broke new ground. I dread to think what would happen if this were TS1 or 2, but here WALL-E wins for me.
on 3/19/2012
Toy Story 3. It is the best one in my opinion. Wall E is in my top 5 though.
Favorite animation*
on 8/9/2012
Toy Story 3 just broke my heart. It was a great ending to the trilogy and an amazing movie, but it just pulled a little too much at the heart strings. Wall-e was a break through in animation and storytelling, so Wall-e gets my pick.
on Apr 18
Hmm . . . I'm going with Wall-E here, because not only is it an original creation by Pixar, but it also manages to convey so much emotion from the main characters with little-no dialogue.
on Apr 19
Toy Story 3= The Greatest Animated Film of All-Time
