Sign In Now ►
or Create A New Account ►
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
Not even close here, X3 all day and twice on Sunday. Sin City is overrated and, quite frankly, juvenile. "R" rated yet completely juvenile proves that it takes more than boobies and fake gun play to make a quality film.
Do we really have to compare one of the best comic-book adaptations to one of the worst? Sin City all the way, awesome movie.
I didn't like Sin City. Visually unique, that's all I can really say for it. The Last Stand is severely flawed, but I'd rather watch it again any day of the week.
Sin City was a real trip. I loved it.
Sin City may very well be overrated, but X-men: The Last Stand was simply awful. I'd vote either of the first two over Sin City, but have to go against X3 here.