Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
2 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 9/12/2013
Once Upon a Time in the West is my pick. Both are masterpieces, but West has better dialogue and better characters in my opinion. It is also more entertaining and more rewatchable.
on 12/2/2014
Epic showdown. OUATITW for me.
on 1/22/2015
Tommy DeVito and Jimmy Conway to execute everyone in The West.
on 10/26/2019
Wow this is a really tough decision. Both films are great but I'm going to go with Goodfellas just because I've seen it more times. This can always change though.