Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
10 comments
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/13/2009
This is a difficult decision for me, but I'm going with The Usual Suspects.
on 7/16/2009
Probably one of the hardest discisions of my life.
on 2/15/2014
Hate to revive this because I feel like the mobster crowd will flood this poll in favor of Goodfellas. I love Goodfellas and it is a quality film. It's probably my favorite mafia movie. I even enjoy it better than Godfather. Of course Godfather is a better film, but Goodfellas was simply more enjoyable. But in this particular matchup, Suspects wins for me. I'm just a sucker for mystery and suspense.
Let the flooding begin!
Let the flooding continue!
*Piccolo comes out of nowhere and tries to stop the flooding*
on 2/28/2014
*Piccolo is overwhelmed by the continuous surge of water, as he drowns... *
Two amazing films. Both in my top 100. Both with classic last lines. Both worthy of winning this head-to-head battle. I have Goodfellas winning.
on 4/10/2014
Besides Kevin Spacey's performance, the mystery and the twist, I don't get the mass praise for The Usual Suspects. You may argue that GoodFellas is kind of overrated as well, but a Scorsese gangster film beats Suspects by a long distance.
on 8/2/2014
They're Both Very good films. I 'm going to Say GoodFellas.
on 11/16/2014
Suspects is fantastic but GoodFellas is in my Top 20.
on 8/4/2015
Goodfellas.It is the far better movie and as good as Kevin Spacey was Joe pesci was better than him.
on 8/14/2015
I like this matchup. Both are top 50 for me. I think for the better plot I'll take Usual Suspects.
on 3/5/2017
Close, but it goes to the Suspects
on 9/8/2018
goodfellas is a masterpiece the usual suspects was great but not as much at level of goodfellas
on 9/9/2018
Goodfellas is a great film but I do find it kinda overrated. Whatever, it's still a Scorsese crime thriller so that beats 80% of movies out there, including the gimmicky and uneven Usual Suspects!
