Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
13 comments
6 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 12/15/2010
AHHHHHHH MY BRAIN IS GOING TO EXPLODE, DON'T MAKE ME CHOOSE!!!
on 3/10/2012
Fellowship of the Ring. Just EPIC.
on 7/6/2012
both are great but lotr is FANTASTIK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
on 7/23/2012
Fight Club is fun but LotR is just perfect.
on 8/19/2012
Fightclub is better cinema if you include all of the nit-picky things but Lotr is still fantastic.
on 11/27/2012
Two great films cemented in my top 10. But Lord of the Rings has been with me much longer.
on 6/24/2013
As much as I love Fight Club, its gotta be Lord of the Rings.
on 8/23/2013
FOTR easily beats the overrated Fight Club.
The LotR trilogy is fantastic, but this is David Fincher's masterpiece we're talking about. I have to pick Fight Club.
on 8/24/2013
Gotta pick Lord of the Rings.
on 2/17/2014
Though they are both based on books, Fight Club needs to do much more interesting things to work as a movie. I'll go with Fight Club without second thought.
on 5/11/2014
I'm Going with LotR
on 1/11/2015
Fellowship has an hour of very unique pastoral fantasy followed by well-done action fantasy. Many vote for Fellowship on its scale and grandeur; I vote on it for Hobbit-holes.
on 2/8/2015
LOTR.
on 12/5/2015
Fellowship for me. Hard choice.
on 8/8/2018
LotR folks...
on 10/16/2018
Lord of the Rings once more.
on 7/23/2021
Tyler Durden > Gandalf.
Fight club purely overrated ahead not simple