The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring vs. Fight Club

13 comments

6 comments

AHHHHHHH MY BRAIN IS GOING TO EXPLODE, DON'T MAKE ME CHOOSE!!!

Fellowship of the Ring. Just EPIC.

both are great but lotr is FANTASTIK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Fight Club is fun but LotR is just perfect.

Fightclub is better cinema if you include all of the nit-picky things but Lotr is still fantastic.

Two great films cemented in my top 10. But Lord of the Rings has been with me much longer.

As much as I love Fight Club, its gotta be Lord of the Rings.

FOTR easily beats the overrated Fight Club.

The LotR trilogy is fantastic, but this is David Fincher's masterpiece we're talking about. I have to pick Fight Club.

Gotta pick Lord of the Rings.

Though they are both based on books, Fight Club needs to do much more interesting things to work as a movie. I'll go with Fight Club without second thought.

I'm Going with LotR

Fellowship has an hour of very unique pastoral fantasy followed by well-done action fantasy. Many vote for Fellowship on its scale and grandeur; I vote on it for Hobbit-holes.

LOTR.

Fellowship for me. Hard choice.

LotR folks...

Lord of the Rings once more.

Tyler Durden > Gandalf.

Fight club purely overrated ahead not simple