Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
19 comments
13 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 1/5/2010
:(
on 1/8/2010
on 1/20/2010
on 3/6/2010
I'm going for the one that was a capstone, rather than the one diminished by inferior sequels. How bout you?
on 5/20/2010
The Good, the Bad and the muthafuckin Masterful!
on 7/19/2010
*covers face* awww...hell...
on 1/26/2011
2 Brilliant films,i cant make my mind up on witch one to pick. Im just going to have to pick the one that ive watched the most. Star Wars...:)
on 4/19/2011
sigh - ok *flexes mouse fingers*...Both indelible imprints on my brain. It's really performance vs. story, IMO. damn. Rare event; Star Wars gets outgunned :\
No question...Star Wars...
on 4/20/2011
Star Wars was a movie I was introduced to when I was barely old enough to write. I saw The Good, the Bad and the Ugly for the first time on TV one Sunday afternoon when I was teenager. Looking at my movie tastes now, The Good has had a much larger impact on my movie watching than Star Wars. In fact, Star Wars doesn't have any real influence on my tastes at all these days. I can say that Star Wars had a big impact on my youth, and few movies entertained me as much back then, but now those are fond memories and little more. The Good served as a gateway to more diverse and mature movie tastes, and I still think it's one of the most exhilarating movies I've ever seen. Star Wars doesn't hold up the same way, even though I still enjoy it.
on 4/21/2011
Star Wars was a landmark film and I respect that but I've never been a huge fan. The Good, the Bad and the Ugly is just as iconic, something I keep going back to and I enjoyed it a lot more so I'm going with that.
on 7/5/2011
I think this is truly the toughest call I've ever had to make with films. Both have a huge impact on my tastes in story, characters, styles, and themes. The Good is a lesson about the ambiguity of humans who lived in the west with subtle anti-war messages that almost accidently find their way into the film. Star Wars is a space opera, borrowing from chobura, spaghetti westerns, and countless others to make something that seemed familiar yet completely new at the same time. I think if it weren't for the fact Star Wars needs sequels to complete the story, it would win, but seeing as The Bad is more self contained than Star Wars, I would have to go with The Ugly here.
on 5/7/2012
star wars really isn't that great where as GBU is the greatest film of all time
on 10/29/2012
Star Wars for me. It's been apart of me longer.
on 2/13/2013
I'm sorry Star Wars. The Good absolutely kills you.
on 2/14/2013
Yeah I feel ya rob, Star Wars for me too.
on 5/31/2013
Star Wars wins in an extremely close matchup.
on 6/6/2013
SW here as well, very close though
on 6/13/2013
Star Wars for sure.
on 6/20/2013
Star Wars hammers here.
on 11/19/2013
on 8/3/2014
It's a tough choice but Star Wars draws the short straw here.
on 8/4/2014
:)
on 8/11/2014
on 8/4/2015
The Good, The Bad and the Ugly actually.
on 8/5/2015
Good, Bad, Ugly wins slightly.
on 8/23/2015
Star Wars is the one I'd rather watch. GBU is still great, though.
on 7/18/2018
TGTBATU beats the original Star Wars..
on 5/25/2019
Never mind it's Star Wars.
on 11/4/2019
Star Wars barely definitely deserves the win here.
on 8/6/2020
For now the good the bad and ugly makes the best reference classic here.
on 8/16/2020
I'm leaning toward Star Wars as of now. Two great films that have helped define my taste in movies.
on 12/27/2022
My 2nd favorite Sci-fi film or my favorite western. I love sci-fi movies more but TGBU wins easily.
