Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
6 comments
8 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/14/2009
Ouch. I really don't know which one is better here. This is harder than I thought.
on 10/19/2009
Huge fan of both films, but slighty more towards 'Unbreakable'.
on 3/18/2010
Unbreakable is unfairly maligned, and Fight Club is unduly lauded. Give me Willis and Samuel L. any day.
on 7/23/2010
Unbreakable gets it.
Fight Club scores another knockout but Unbreakable is a worthy opponent.
on 9/7/2010
Difficult decision... I never understood why Unbreakable has such a bad reputation. It's a thinking man's superhero movie, and it's great. Wins by a long shot here, although Fight Club was, obviously, brilliant.
on 4/11/2011
I must be one of the few people around here who didn't like Fight Club.
on 2/29/2012
Gotta go with Unbreakable here, I like Fight Club a lot but I feel Unbreakable builds tension better and with Fight Club I kind of lose interest when it gets to Project Mayhem. Both good films but Unbreakable does more for me.
on 6/11/2013
Unbreakable is great, but Fight Club is legendary.
on 1/16/2019
Unbreakable is underrated but it really can’t compete with Fight Club.
on 1/17/2019
Unbreakable...but I don't love either...
Unbreakable without hesitation. Fight Club has overstayed its welcome in my top 100.
I'm quite mixed on Fight Club but, even though Unbreakable isn't near my top 100, I still see it as a great film because of what it set out to do!
on 9/21/2023
Both great films but I'd go with Unbreakable by just a hair.
Fuck unbreakable. Fight Club is better. I dreamt of scenes in Fight Club.
