Sign In Now ►
or Create A New Account ►
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
It pains me to go against a childhood favorite like Return of the Jedi, but The Dark Knight is one awesome movie.
This isn't an easy choice, but if you think about it while you're watching, Maggie Gyllenhall looks a lot like Carrie Fisher, and that makes the choice very slightly easier.
easy. tdk -Yeah Man (Usher Voice)-
TDK didn't have Ewoks, so... yeah, TDK wins.
Jedi......even though the involvement of Zeus almost put me over the edge for TDK.
What SquareMaster said. The Dark Knight wins.
Head says TDK, heart says Jedi. Think I'll follow my heart on this one, even though both are excellent. Whenever the Ewoks appear I just use the fast-forward button ;P
Despite being old enough I was a child when "Jedi" opened, I didn't get into "Star Wars" until the 90s. I'm not emotionally beholden to it the same way so many from my generation are. I rather like "Jedi," and I've said more than once I think it's the most fun of the OT to watch. But for me, Batman > "Star Wars" in general, and while I'm not as in love with TDK as many, I still enjoy it enough to pick it here.
Return of the Jedi for me. It holds up much better in the long term run.
Both are top 10 for me. The Dark Knight barely wins it.