Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
2 comments
4 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/24/2009
Two of my favorite teen comedies. Going with American Pie because without it there would probably be no Girl Next Door.
on 4/3/2012
Ugh! Both suck, but that bird from the girl next door is well worth it, if you ask me.
on 5/13/2014
American Pie's Hijinx is enough for the win One time at band camp lol !!
American Pie for me.
on 2/16/2018
I love both. I’ll take the pie as well
on 5/30/2022
I never cared all that much for any of the American Pie movies tbh, and I don't really know why... I'm not gonna pretend Girl Next Door is some underrated masterwork, but it is a movie I can put on and have solid time with, more so than AP.