Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
4 comments
1 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 11/2/2009
Not a big fan of either. I'll go watchman because of Earle Haley's performance.
on 8/5/2011
Both had strong casts, but Batman Begins had less flaws and more poignancy.
on 6/30/2012
Both good, but going to go with Batman. Arguably, Christopher Nolan had a less demanding challenge than Zack Snyder; all he had to do was make it better than the Schumacher films. He not only succeeded, but surpassed all expectations. Watchmen was a tougher film to make, and while it is both very good and my favourite Snyder film (not much seeing as the others I've seen I either hate or care little for), there's no denying that it suffers from a muddled plot and episodic feel. Batman doesn't suffer from this, so Batman it is.
batman begins for me i was hugely dissapointed in watchmen
Not a fan of Batman Begins' second half, so I'm going with Watchmen.
