Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
13 comments
1 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/7/2009
Oh damn, this is sort of a hard match up. I like the LOTR movies better than Narnia... but I didn't like Return of the King as much as I would have...
on 8/11/2009
So many LOTR ripoffs since Return of the King came out.... But while Narnia is one of the better attempts to recapture that particular brand of movie magic, it still doesn't hold a candle to Jackson's amazing trilogy.
on 10/24/2009
ah -toughie i love both
on 6/8/2010
AH! I didn't like either of these! I'm not a LOTR fan... by any means.. and Narnia...yea...no. ugh... I guess i'd have to choose..... LOTR. Cuz I can fall asleep faster... sorry if I offended any one out there... I just am not a fan.
on 7/23/2010
Easy choice. I like the LOTR books better then CON, and I like the LOTR movies WAAY better.
on 7/28/2010
I don't just like Narnia--I love it. But yeah, it's no LOTR.
on 7/29/2010
Both good Fantasy films based on successful books. I think I'll have to go with "Return of the King" for its advantages of overall film quality compared to Disney's Narnia. Also, there's the dozen or so Oscars...
on 6/29/2011
Love LOTR but Return of the King was way too long. Narnia was awful, so it's an easy choice.
on 7/6/2012
is this a joke?
on 1/8/2013
Narnia was a good movie, no doubt about that and very enjoyable HOWEVER Lord of the Rings is far greater in every aspect compared to Narnia
on 7/11/2013
I'm gonna change my original statement a bit and say that the first Narnia film isn't necessarily a great one but is something I found enjoyable. However, once more it isn't LOTR. The Hobbit is also superior to Narnia
on 4/12/2014
I dont understand the hate that Narnia get. Is is because Narnia has Christian meanings to it? Guess what, so does LOTR. CS Lewis became a Christian through Tolkein
on 1/11/2017
I loved them both
on 8/24/2019
My first one and already TOO HARD TO CHOOSE!
on 10/26/2021
Narnia is a good film, but it's absolutely nothing compared to the incredible ROTK
