Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
14 comments
10 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 7/11/2009
crap!!! dang!!! ....aaaarrrggghh!!
C'mon! E.T. is WAY better!!!
on 7/12/2009
Yeah I have to go with E.T. as well.
on 7/14/2009
Tear my heart out why don't you! Two of my all-time faves... Nightmare, barely. And I mean barely barely.
on 9/8/2009
No, it's Nightmare all the way!
on 9/18/2009
Nightmare- E.T. is damn good, but those "NIGHTMARE" songs are classic. Plus, Jack Skellington's transformation is beautiful!!!!!!
on 9/24/2009
This is a no brainer. Nightmare wins by a long shot. Definitly one of Tim Burton's best films yet.
on 10/14/2009
Nightmare before Christmas. One of my first Burton Storys and one of the best Films ever. Just love those lovingly animated Characters.
on 11/15/2009
So tough... But I have to go with Jack here.
on 2/16/2010
I think this one can only be decided by one's generation. I admire the artistry of "NBX," but I cut my movie-watching teeth on "E.T." (It's my earliest memory of going to the theater.)
on 4/12/2010
Both are classics, but The Nightmare Before Christmas has so much going for it: the characters, the songs, the animation. It wins, hands down.
on 11/1/2010
I think minlshaw is right your choice might be defined by your generation and mine comes with Nightmare, this is very tough, very very tough, though.
on 12/30/2010
"Nightmare" has been with me since I was 11 years old. "E.T." has been with me my entire life. These are both beautiful movies. If there is a generational difference, it is only a difference of a couple years. (I know how old you are, shadownate....)
on 2/12/2012
There comes a point every time that I watch "E.T." where I feel like its spell is broken and I become cynical about it. But then, before the movie ends, it reestablishes its hold on me. I can't choose NBX over it.
on 8/26/2012
Nightmare, of course like any person with a heart I love E.T. but the songs of Nightmare and the Stop-motion are what makes it just come out on top, this wasn't an easy choice
on 12/20/2012
Ugh. Eat a dick.
on 2/10/2013
Both of theses films were disappointing.Over all The Nightmare Before Christmas is better.
Nightmare before Christmas, love tim burton movies :D
on 5/30/2013
Nightmare easy, just aged better and was more unique.
Got no problem going ET here. I have no love for TNBC....
on 6/18/2013
E.T. by miles, even though I enjoy Nightmare a lot.
on 6/25/2013
E.T by a landslide.
on 11/25/2013
NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS! E.T is the creepiest crap ever put on the universe, The Nightmare before Christmas wins by miles.
on 3/12/2014
^Not gonna lie, E.T. used to be the scariest thing in my life for a good 10 years, couldn't bear to watch, but now I love it with all my heart. Nightmare has grown on me too, but not nearly as much, and E.T., for better or for worse, has had a bigger impact on my life.
on 4/18/2014
ET but this was very close
on 3/5/2015
ET is great, but i'll go with the best Burton's story
on 12/4/2020
I saw Nightmare when I was 12 years old, the Music, the Story, the Stop Motion. One of my favorites. Nightmare winst.
