Sign In Now ► or Create A New Account ►
11 comments
3 comments
Rank This Matchup or Comment/Reply Below
on 8/8/2009
A tough choice....because of the Tarantino factor. However, some say that Pulp doesn't hold up as well...still...it's the better film.
Cineastes will debate this choice for years.
on 8/12/2009
Drexel.
on 11/20/2009
Seriously, how can you pick. Love Quentin's direction but Tony pulled off his script. Shit, this is so tough. I do LOVE Gary Oldman - shit
on 4/27/2010
True Romance is much more interesting because it may be the only time we see a Tarantino script (not story) directed by someone else. It's a great movie but Pulp Fiction wins hands down.
on 4/28/2010
Pulp Fiction has that interesting time structure and the memorable characters giving it the edge here.
on 8/27/2010
Sophie's Choice!
Hmmm...Pulp Fiction takes it for sheer enjoyment.
on 9/5/2010
True Romance is good, but even if it had been directed by Tarantino I don't think it would top Pulp Fiction.
on 8/25/2011
Man i just ranked KKBB over TR.. if you take away the amazing production of pulp fiction and the cast and just look at it in the bare bones.. read them like a comic book, true romance has more entertainment value, where pulp fiction just has more crazy epic shit happening but here i think true romance wins..
on 12/28/2012
True Romance: the Tarantino flick that's not really a Tarantino flick (Tony Scott behind the camera does make somewhat of a difference) yet still is a Tarantino flick (dialogue, violence, casting, characters). And like Pulp Fiction, I liked it, I didn't love it. Something about Tarantino's writing just doesn't really appeal to me. It is good dialogue, without a doubt, but it's not really focused on the story. Like that scene with Christopher Walken and Dennis Hopper: it's a great scene, but wasn't its length a little...ehm...pointless? I dunno. Anyway, I'm just not a big fan of Tarantino. Reservoir Dogs and Inglourious Basterds are great, but I'm kind of 'meh' to his other stuff. In the end, I think I liked Pulp Fiction a little better. It has better performances and more memorable moments, and it doesn't have music in the background constantly like in True Romance (yeah, it's a nitpick, I know).
on 12/29/2012
Pulp
on Mar 10
This is tough. Both are Tarantino at his best, but I think with Tarantino's direction give Pulp Fiction the edge.
I have no problem going True Romance on this one. Love Pulp....but True Romance always delivers...
